Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Supreme Court of Ohio: Ruling illustrates transparency alone insufficient in public records request

 

Supreme Court of Ohio: Ruling illustrates transparency alone insufficient in public records request

KEITH ARNOLD, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

The Ohio Supreme Court articulated in a recent ruling of a public records request that timelines or diligence, at least, is just as essential as the underlying record requested.

The court wrote per curiam that the woman who originally requested public records related to a 2007 criminal case in Guernsey County was entitled to damages in the amount of $1,000.

State law provides for statutory damages of $100 per business day, up to $1,000, if a court determines that a public office failed to comply with a public records request.

"The primary duty of a public office when it has received a public records request is to promptly provide any responsive records within a reasonable amount of time and when a records request is denied, to inform the requester of that denial and provide the reasons for that denial," justices wrote.

LaDonna Cordell, on Aug. 9, 2017, sent Guernsey County Sheriff Jeffrey Paden a letter by regular U.S. Mail seeking public records relating to the criminal case (State v. Bates, Guernsey C.P. No. 07 CR 117) against Bryan Bates.

The request sought copies of scientific tests, as well as the scientists' notes and reports, police investigative records and work product, and any witness statements, according to the case summary.

Paden, in response, sent Cordell an incident report from a search warrant that had been executed against Bates pursuant to the sheriff's office's continuing criminal investigation against him.

Justices noted that while the incident report possibly addressed one of Cordell's requests, there is no evidence that the sheriff included a responsive letter with the incident report addressing Cordell's other five record requests.

Cordell claimed that the incident report was nonresponsive, prompting her to send a second request by certified mail Aug. 18, 2017.

Paden did not respond to that second request, the summary noted.

Cordell filed Oct. 5, 2017 an original action in the Supreme Court seeking a writ of mandamus to compel the sheriff to provide the requested records.

During the mandamus action's pendency, Paden - through the Guernsey County Prosecuting Attorney - provided Cordell with Bates' file and the same incident report he had sent in August.

The prosecuting attorney also informed Cordell that other agencies had conducted the forensic tests and that certain documents were not subject to disclosure.

The woman continued requesting the records and the sheriff continued responding that other than the incident report, his office had no additional records and that other requested records were exempt from disclosure.

The parties do not dispute that the sheriff's office is a public office subject to the requirements of the Public Records Act, the court continued.

"The sheriff, however, has no duty to create or provide access to nonexistent records," justices wrote, citing State ex rel. Lanham v. Smith, 112 Ohio St.3d 527, 2007-Ohio-609, 861 N.E.2d 530. "It is Cordell's burden to prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that the records that she requested exist and are public records maintained by the sheriff's office.

"Cordell argues that because the state could not have arrested and convicted Bates without forensic tests, witness statements, investigative reports, etc., those records must exist. But the sheriff has repeatedly informed Cordell that his office did not conduct any of those tests and therefore does not have the results and other state or federal agencies that may have conducted the tests would likely have custody of any test results."

On the basis that the woman failed to prove that the requested records exist or that they are in the custody of the sheriff's office, her mandamus claim for the production of records was denied.

"Regarding Cordell's first records request, Cordell has shown that the sheriff's response was incomplete," justices concluded. "Other than sending the incident report, which was arguably responsive to one category of records, there is no evidence that the sheriff responded to the rest of Cordell's public-records requests.

"And the sheriff failed to respond to Cordell's second request until almost three months after Cordell made the request by certified mail and approximately 43 days after she filed her mandamus petition, making the sheriff's second response unreasonably delayed."

State law required Paden to not only provide the relevant records that he had but to state clearly that no additional records were in his custody.

The high court has previously awarded statutory damages when a public office ignored a records request for several months, the decision noted.

Justices reasoned the woman was entitled to the maximum amount of statutory damages on the basis that the sheriff never provided the court with an explanation of why he failed to appropriately respond to Cordell's requests within a reasonable period of time.

"Therefore, we find no basis to reduce the amount of statutory damages awarded in this case," justices wrote.

The case is cited as State ex rel. Cordell v. Paden, Slip Opinion No. 2019-Ohio-1216.

Date Published: April 29, 2019

 

Copyright © 2019 The Daily Reporter - All Rights Reserved

 

Member of Dayton carjacking conspiracy pleads guilty

Carlos Raymond Alvarez, aka “Rico Finessegod”, 25, of Dayton, pleaded guilty in U.S. District Court to conspiracy to commit carjacking and gun charges for his role in a scheme that lured a victim through a dating app and stole his car when he showed up for his expected date.

UD’s Jake Gilkison finishes in top five at Rutherford Intercollegiate

Jake Gilkison continued to play strong as the Flyers finished strong at the Rutherford Open. Dayton finished in 9th place. The team as a whole shot a 298 + 301 + 289 = 888 (+36). The team was led by Jake Gilkison, who shot a 72 + 71 + 68 = 211 (-2). His impressive three days included an Eagle on the day. This was the second-best finish in the storied career of the Senior from Springboro, Ohio.

Fish dealer sentenced for unlawful trafficking in Michigan lake trout

John H. Cross III (Cross) and John Cross Fisheries Inc. (Cross Fisheries) were sentenced recently in Kalamazoo, Michigan, for trafficking in illegally transported and sold lake trout, announced Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Bossert Clark for the Justice Department’s Environment and Natural Resources Division and United States Attorney Andrew Birge for the Western District of Michigan. Cross Fisheries was also sentenced for making false records about whitefish purchases.

Rural courts, sheriffs convene with feds to combat opioids

The opioid epidemic has created a crime and treatment crisis for all kinds of American communities. But the ones that may be most affected are small and rural jurisdictions.

New Oh SNAP mobile phone app provides food assistance information

A new Oh SNAP mobile phone application has detailed information about the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and other food programs, not only for Ohioans receiving benefits but for those who think they may be eligible. It’s available for free on mobile devices through the App Store or Google Play.

BGSU research team sheds light on penguin evolution

Dr. Juan Bouzat, a professor in Bowling Green State University’s Department of Biological Sciences, is part of an international research team studying the evolution of penguins. He is a co-author of a study published in the journal of the Society for Molecular Biology and Evolution that demonstrates the importance of island formation in the diversification of penguins and posits the discovery of two extinct penguin species from New Zealand. The research, recently highlighted by the New York Times, was conducted by a diverse team of 19 scholars representing eight countries and 16 research institutions and universities.

Former CFO at publicly traded transportation company charged with $245 million securities and accounting fraud scheme

Big Lots launches spring campaign benefiting Nationwide Children's

Columbus-based Big Lots has announced the launch of its spring point-of-sale campaign, "Serve Families. Give Big." to benefit Nationwide Children's Hospital.

Senate bill would add two weeks to save speedy-trial violations

A state senator and attorney by trade hopes to correct what he and state prosecutors believe is the disproportionate penalty that results from violation of Ohio's speedy trial statute.

Ohio's 2019 wild turkey season coming soon

For many hunters, spring brings the unmistakable sound of gobbling wild turkeys as Ohio’s annual hunt of this popular game bird begins, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR). The state is divided into two zones for the 2019 spring turkey hunting season: a south zone, which opens to hunters on Monday, April 22, and a northeast zone, which opens to hunters on Monday, April 29. Hunters can view the 2019 spring turkey season zone map at wildohio.gov.

Seven Ohio men plead guilty to crimes related to sexually abusing children, creating child pornography

Seven Ohio men have pleaded guilty to related crimes regarding child pornography and the sexual abuse of two 10-year-old children.

The Ohio Children’s Trust Fund recognizes #EverydayOhioHeroes for child abuse prevention month

April is Child Abuse Prevention Month, and the Ohio Children’s Trust Fund encourages all Ohioans to join the #EverydayOhioHeroes campaign to recognize everyday heroes who make our community a safe place for families and children. Use #EverydayOhioHeroes on social media to recognize those making a difference.

Former Ohio attorney general Dann goes after BMV for bogus $1.50 fees

A Cleveland law firm headed by former Ohio Attorney General Marc Dann filed a class action lawsuit on behalf of Ohioans who paid for a false laminating fee of $1.50 since late last year when deputy registrars' ceased distributing state license and ID cards.

Summary for proposed presidential election amendment certified

The Ohio Attorney General’s Office recently certified a summary of a petition for a proposed amendment to the Ohio Constitution. The proposed amendment would change the way Ohio’s Electoral College members vote in presidential elections. An alternative summary for the same proposed amendment was rejected.

Man indicted for allegedly committing five armed robberies in December 2018

A Cleveland man was indicted for allegedly committing five armed robberies in December 2018.

Three charged with filing $1.9 million in false tax returns

Two defendants plead guilty

2019 Lake Erie fishing outlook is once again great news for anglers

Lake Erie anglers have the chance to experience excellent fishing opportunities on Lake Erie in 2019, according to Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) Division of Wildlife. Walleye angler harvest rates set records in 2018, and numerous large hatches point to a bright future for the Walleye Capital of the World.

Jury finds Toledo pastor guilty of sex trafficking of a minor and other crimes

A jury found a Toledo pastor guilty of sex trafficking of a minor and other crimes, U.S. Attorney Justin E. Herdman and FBI Special Agent in Charge Eric B. Smith said.

Bill would providing privacy shield to mental health workers

A bipartisan effort to expand privacy protections for certain mental health workers cleared the Ohio House of Representatives recently and awaits Senate consideration.

Ohio probate judge publicly reprimanded for presiding over ex-client cases

The Ohio Supreme Court recently publicly reprimanded a Mahoning County probate judge for taking action as a judge on cases in which he previously served as a lawyer. The Court noted there was no evidence that Rusu’s misconduct caused any measurable harm or that it “resulted in anything less than the evenhanded administration of justice.”