Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Panel explores issues in wake of Lucia v. SEC decision


Panel explores issues in wake of Lucia v. SEC decision

The U.S. Supreme Court recently resolved a circuit split regarding the constitutionality of administrative law judge (ALJ) appointments, holding that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) can no longer consider ALJs “employees” exempt from the U.S. Constitution’s Appointments Clause.

In Lucia v. SEC, the Court held that ALJs exercise “significant” authority, “comparable to that of a federal district court judge conducting a bench trial,” and thus are “Officers of the United States” who, under Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 of the Constitution, must be appointed by the President, “Courts of Law,” or “Heads of Departments” rather than SEC staff. The decision overturned a ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit concluding that SEC ALJs were employees rather than officers.

Following the June 2018 decision, President Donald J. Trump issued an executive order excepting administrative law judges from the competitive service. The order announced that each agency should be empowered to assess “critical qualities” in ALJ candidates, such as work ethic, judgment, and ability to meet the particular needs of the agency, which will help “promote confidence in, and the durability of, agency adjudications.”

In short, the SEC judges were deemed powerful enough that they should be chosen by agency leaders, the president or a court, rather than being hired as traditional employees through the selection process the SEC had long used.

The impact of Lucia has already spread to all federal agencies, affecting thousands of ALJs by potentially requiring compliance with the Appointments Clause across the board.

A panel at the 2018 American Bar Association Section of Administrative Law and Regulatory Practice Fall Conference discussed the ramifications of Lucia. Moderated by John Vittone, former chief judge of the U.S. Department of Labor’s Office of Administrative Law Judges, panelists included:

Linda D. Jellum, professor of tax law at Mercer University School of Law

Jennifer Mascott, assistant professor of law at Antonin Scalia Law School at George Mason University

Mark Perry, partner at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP

Richard J. Pierce, professor of law at the George Washington University Law School

Lucia and the Executive Order addresses ALJ appointments, but leaves questions about ALJ removal up in the air. Currently, ALJ removal under existing SEC internal procedures requires a good cause determination by the Merit Systems Protection Board, which provides job protections and due process for federal employees.

Mascott predicts more cases coming before the Court, as it needs to define what firing “for good cause” means, for example. Recently the Department of Labor announced it would have a hiring system within their department that woud be very similar to the Office of Personnel Management system, using objective standards to make hiring decisions.

Pierce opened with 15 questions he says remain unanswered from the Lucia decision, mostly related to operational issues. For example, will all 11,000-plus non-adjudicatory personnel be classified as inferior officers? It may take years for questions like these to be resolved, he said.

Jellum agreed that one issue of concern is who exactly does Lucia apply to? The Supreme Court previously has held that very minor individuals such as district court clerks are inferior officers. Then there are several removal issues, which may be the most difficult to sort out as they involve varying levels of protections.

Perry said defenders of the status quo want to cast Lucia as insignificant, but he in his view the agencies of the federal government should not operate as an independent, unaccountable fourth branch of government.

About the American Bar Association

With more than 400,000 members, the American Bar Association is one of the largest voluntary professional membership organizations in the world. As the national voice of the legal profession, the ABA works to improve the administration of justice, promotes programs that assist lawyers and judges in their work, accredits law schools, provides continuing legal education, and works to build public understanding around the world of the importance of the rule of law. View our privacy statement online. Follow the latest ABA news at and on Twitter @ABANews.

Date Published: November 28, 2018


American Bar Association


Wright State University agrees to pay government $1 million for visa fraud

Wright State University’s Board of Trustees has accepted responsibility for visa fraud offenses on behalf of the university and agreed to pay the federal government $1 million.

Settlement expected to improve Ohio's special education system

An organization championing the rights of Ohio special education students announced last week that it had arrived at a settlement with the state in a 25-year-old class action lawsuit seeking sufficient resources for the public instruction of disabled students.

Attorney General DeWine offers holiday shopping tips for consumers

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine recently offered consumer protection tips for the holiday shopping season.

Legislation proposed to ensure financial resources for counties of capital crimes involving multiple victims and defendants

When a multi-defendant capital crime occurs in a county with limited resources, local officials may be unable to seek justice because of the extraordinary cost of prosecuting such a case. Recently, Ohio Auditor Dave Yost was joined by Senator Bob Peterson and Representative Shane Wilkin to call for legislation to address the financial strain on a community brought on by cases involving multiple victims and defendants.

Chinese national sentenced to nearly six years in prison for distributing opioids and other drugs that were shipped from China to the U.S. and ultimately to Ohio

A Chinese national who had been living in Massachusetts was sentenced to nearly six years in prison for distributing opioids and other drugs that were shipped from China to the United States and ultimately to Ohio.

Ohio's young hunters harvest more than 6,500 deer during youth gun season

Ohio’s young hunters had a successful weekend and checked 6,563 white-tailed deer during the two-day youth gun season, Nov. 17-18, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR). During last year’s youth gun season, 4,958 white-tailed deer were checked.

Kroger shooting suspect charged with federal hate crimes and firearm offenses

Gregory A. Bush, 51, was indicted recently by a federal grand jury on hate crime and firearm charges arising out of the racially motivated murder of two African-American patrons at a Kroger grocery store, and the attempted murder of a third, on Oct. 24 in Jeffersontown, Kentucky. The indictment was announced by Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker, Assistant Attorney General Eric Dreiband for the Civil Rights Division, U.S. Attorney Russell Coleman, and FBI Louisville Special Agent in Charge James Robert Brown, Jr.

Proposed legislation designed to make children safer in homes with guns

Lawmakers in the Ohio House of Representatives heard testimony recently about a measure that would criminalize a Ohio gun owner's failure to secure or make a firearm inoperable in circumstances in which a minor may gain access to the weapon.

Former nonprofit executive director arrested and charged with embezzling $172,000

A former executive director of a Cleveland community development corporation was arrested this morning for embezzling more than $172,000 from the Collinwood and Nottingham Villages Development Corporation.

Secretary Husted releases new business filings figures

Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted just recently announced 10,876 new entities filed to do business in Ohio last month, an increase of 1,626 when compared to October 2017.

Ohio Peace Officer Training Academy receives $280,000 in grants for law enforcement training courses

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine recently announced that his office’s Ohio Peace Officer Training Academy has received two grants totaling $280,000 to provide training for Ohio law enforcement officers on topics including identifying impaired drivers and investigating traffic collisions.

Bar admission caps years-long journeys for almost 600 new attorneys

Nearly 600 attorneys took their oaths and received their certificates to practice law before all seven justices at the Ohio Supreme Court’s annual fall bar admission ceremony at the Palace Theatre in Columbus.

Football runs past Morehead State, 63-20

On a chilly Saturday afternoon at Welcome Stadium, the Dayton Flyers' offense came out on fire and took control of the game well before halftime.

Public Health provides bikeway signs with the goal of increasing physical activity

Public Health - Dayton & Montgomery County’s Creating Healthy Communities (CHC) program has provided bikeway signs in Old North Dayton to direct residents to the Great Miami Recreation Trail, Mad River Recreation Tail, Stuart Patterson Park, and other Old North Dayton destinations. The goal of the project is to increase the number of Old North Dayton residents who have access to places for physical activity.

WSU men’s basketball slips at Murray State

The Wright State men's basketball team went on the road Saturday, November 10, for their first game away from the Nutter Center and fell at Murray State 73-54. WSU is now 1-1 while the Racers are 1-0.

Clerk outsmarts phony owner of Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Comp rebate check

An Akron sex offender added forgery to his criminal record last month after a clerk at a Check Smart thwarted his attempt to cash a $5,500 rebate check from the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation (BWC) that belonged to a church-owned day care center.

Proposal would make it legal to post a photo of your ballot

A pair of Republican lawmakers are making an attempt - albeit late in the legislative session - to extend free speech right up to the nearest voting machine.

Newton Falls woman indicted for stealing $377,000 from healthcare plans she administered and using the money to pay personal and business expenses

A 26-count indictment was filed today accusing a Newton Falls resident of stealing more than $375,000 from healthcare plans she administered and using the money to pay for personal and business expenses, said Justin E. Herdman, United States Attorney for the Northern District of Ohio.

PUCO encourages safe driving around motor carriers during the holidays

During the winter holiday season, Ohio’s world-class transportation system will be heavily relied upon as travelers visit family and friends. Ohio ranks fifth as one of the most highly traveled states in the country, even as some areas receive up to 68 inches of snow annually.

Akron man sentenced to nearly 10 years in prison after ordering 500 grams of a fentanyl analogue from China

An Akron man was sentenced to nearly 10 years in prison after ordering 500 grams of a fentanyl analogue from China.