Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Chief Justice O’Connor cites ‘catastrophic’ effects if state Issue 1 passes this fall

 

Chief Justice O’Connor cites ‘catastrophic’ effects if state Issue 1 passes this fall

Maureen O’Connor, Supreme Court of Ohio Chief Justice

Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor has issued the following statement on state Issue 1, a proposed amendment to the Ohio Constitution:

Too many people in our criminal justice system are there because of substance abuse disorders. This is undeniable. We know that substance abuse disorders are a major driver in criminal justice spending. We also know that through long-term treatment and therapy, those addicted can lead law-abiding, productive lives.

Issue 1 on Ohio’s November 6 ballot purports to address this problem by reducing drug possession penalties and directing the savings from reduced incarcerations to expanded drug treatment and resources for crime victims. A superficial reading of Issue 1 could lead voters to see it as a thoughtful, compassionate, and reasonable response to a difficult and intractable problem. It seems so, until you peel back its layers and see that it will have catastrophic consequences for our state. If Issue 1 passes, Ohio may have some of the most lenient drug crime laws in the nation. We could easily become a magnet for substance abuse activity because there will be, in effect, very little consequence to engaging in such behavior.

Let me put the issue in context by explaining just one of Issue 1’s consequences as it relates to possession of fentanyl, a lethal opioid. According to the Ohio Department of Health (ODH), drug overdose (poisoning) deaths in Ohio increased from 3,050 in 2015 to 4,050 in 2016. This is roughly four times the number of people who die in traffic accidents in Ohio annually. The ODH reported that 58.2 percent of the overdose deaths in Ohio in 2016 involved fentanyl compared with only 4 percent in 2013. This dramatic rise is due to the fact that fentanyl is 50 times more potent than heroin. According to the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, it takes just 2 milligrams of fentanyl – an amount barely able to cover Abraham Lincoln’s beard on a penny – to kill the average person. Fentanyl is addictive, lethal, and simple to manufacture. It is easy to smuggle into our country from foreign sources, even using express mail envelopes. Its potency is not just a problem for abusers. It can be absorbed through the skin, putting freight handlers and first responders at serious risk.

Issue 1 would make the possession of powdered fentanyl in amounts less than 20 grams a misdemeanor with only probation as the consequence. This means that a drug offender caught with less than 20 grams walks away with no possibility of jail time. Since the lethal dose of fentanyl is just 2 milligrams (one-thousandth of a gram), 19 grams of fentanyl is enough to kill approximately 10,000 people. So if Issue 1 passes, an offender charged with possession of 19 grams of fentanyl would automatically get probation and could only be charged with a misdemeanor. Issue 1 does this by constitutionally dictating that any drug possession conviction that is now a Felony 4 or Felony 5 would be reduced to a misdemeanor. The requirement of probation ties the hands of the judge when it comes to sentencing. The judge MUST sentence an individual to probation for these offenses under Issue 1. This is unconscionable. Drug dealers would be incentivized to distribute fentanyl in amounts less than 20 grams so those caught possessing it would avoid incarceration.

The lack of consequences for fentanyl possession is shared with possession of other lethal drugs – cocaine, K2, meth and heroin among them. Across the range of illegal substances, many current felonies would become misdemeanors. Who wouldn’t want to set up their drug distribution business in Ohio knowing that possessing 19 grams of fentanyl or lethal amounts of other drugs would result only in a first class misdemeanor with mandatory probation?

The adoption of Issue 1 would, I predict, have another devastating consequence: Severely hampering the use of our very effective drug court programs across this state. Drug courts would be impeded by taking jail time off the table. We know, through multiple studies, that drug courts are effective only when they combine the “carrot” of treatment and support with the “stick” of judicial accountability, including incarceration when needed. It is this carrot-and-stick approach that enables judges and drug court teams to use a variety of tools to help people overcome addiction. But Issue 1, while providing a lot of carrots by expanding treatment, takes away the stick.

We are not talking about possession of marijuana. We are talking about Ohio becoming, in effect, unable by its constitution to offer drug court participation and to incentivize that involvement by the “carrot” of not having a felony conviction record. Who would want to participate in a drug court program knowing that they only face probation for possession of fentanyl, cocaine, methamphetamine, K2, heroin, and so forth? I predict that we will see a severe drop-off in drug court participation at the very moment when it is needed most should voters approve Issue 1.

To make matters worse, Issue 1 would freeze our criminal drug offense laws in time. It expressly mandates that its provisions be implemented based on the laws in effect on January 1, 2018. Our General Assembly couldn’t, by passing a statute, fix all that is wrong with Issue 1. Our elected leaders could not pass laws to contradict Issue 1 – laws meant to keep us safe. Another constitutional amendment would be necessary to repeal or modify the Issue 1 constitutional amendment. This would take another statewide election.

Keep in mind that special interest groups spent more than $4 million to put Issue 1 on the ballot. Those same special interest groups will fully fund a campaign before this November’s election that will try to mislead and confuse you regarding Issue 1. Please don’t be fooled. Do your homework on Issue 1.

The proponents of Issue 1 seek to address a very real problem in our criminal justice system: the impact of substance abuse on our society and our criminal justice system. But by taking a hammer to that problem, the proponents have set Ohio on a dangerous course to adopting some of the most lenient drug laws in the country. It would limit the ability of the state to confront very real dangers, now and in the future, in battling substance abuse. Issue 1 may be well-intentioned in design, but its passage would gravely endanger Ohioans. It would be devastating in effect.

Date Published: September 24, 2018

 

Supreme Court of Ohio

 

UD football comeback falls short at Duquesne, 31-26

The University of Dayton Flyers found themselves down 31-13 at Duquesne late in the third quarter, but UD scored two touchdowns and were stopped on fourth and goal from the 10 with 2:11 left in the game to fall at Duquesne 31-26.

Update regarding intersection of Alex-Bell Road and Mad River Road

Montgomery County Engineer Paul Gruner wants to thank everyone who provided comments on the design alternatives considered for the Alex-Bell Road & Mad River Road intersection. As a result, the Montgomery County Engineer’s Office has identified a preferred alternative and is proceeding to identify potential funding sources.

Cleveland men indicted for committing armed carjackings and using one of the vehicles to steal firearms from a gun store

Two Cleveland men were indicted in federal court for their roles in a conspiracy with included committing armed carjackings around Ohio City, Tremont and Shaker Square and using one of the vehicles to steal firearms from a gun store in Streetsboro.

Ohio man indicted for murder of wife

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and Hocking County Prosecutor Benjamin E. Fickel announced recently that a Logan man has been indicted on charges related to the murder of his wife.

Six startups chosen for 10-week lab at BMW Financial Services in Hilliard

BMW Group Financial Services has announced the selection of six startup companies to undergo a 10-week lab at BMW Financial Services Collaboration Lab at the company's offices in Hilliard.

Deer hunters: Archery season starts tomorrow

Hunters will have their first opportunity to pursue white-tailed deer when archery season opens on Saturday, Sept. 29, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR).

Ohio police detective among 25 law enforcement officers honored as recipients of The Attorney General's award for distinguished service in policing

Canton Police Detective Michael Rastetter was among 25 law enforcement officers and deputies from 12 jurisdictions across the country honored today by Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Justice Department leadership recently as recipients of the second annual Attorney General’s Award for Distinguished Service in Policing, recognizing the exceptional work.

Columbus ranks 34th as 'boomtown'

Central Ohio was among the top 50 metropolitan areas considered to be the "biggest boomtowns" in America.

Attorney General DeWine joins coalition supporting bill aimed at reducing violence against women and helping survivors

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine today joined 55 other state and territorial attorneys general to urge Congress to reauthorize the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA).

Ohio millennials carry some of the highest debt in the country

(Columbus) Central Ohio was among the top 10 largest cities where millennials carried the most debt.

Two Assistant U.S. Attorneys from Northern Ohio and Canton police detective among those honored at Attorney General's Award ceremony

Two Assistant United States Attorneys who successfully prosecuted an international terrorism investigation and a Canton police detective who worked collaboratively to combat the opioid epidemic were among those honored with Justice Department’s highest recognition on Tuesday, September 18th.

Law and Leadership Institute celebrates 10 years of success in shaping Ohio’s legal community

On September 20th, Ohio’s legal professionals and community leaders gathered at the Ohio Statehouse in Columbus to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the Law and Leadership Institute (LLI), a statewide non-profit that works with students from underserved communities to educate and prepare them for success in college, future leadership roles, and careers in the legal profession.

Proposed legislation seeks to recognize Latino contributions to the Buckeye State

Rather than having to introduce and pass a resolution every year to recognize the contributions Latin Americans have made to Ohio, a pair of Latino lawmakers has championed a bill that would codify a Hispanic and Latino Heritage Month.

Law schools across nation to host ABA competitions

Nine law schools will serve as regional hosts for the 2018-19 American Bar Association’s Negotiation Competition: Quinnipiac University School of Law, New York Law School, George Mason University School of Law, Elon University School of Law, Michigan State University College of Law, Alexander Blewett III School of Law at the University of Montana, University of Houston Law Center, Pepperdine University School of Law and Santa Clara University School of Law.

Ohio, Indiana Volunteers of America groups merge into one organization

The Ohio and Indiana affiliates of Volunteers of America have merged into a new organization.

Dayton falls as Southeast Missouri pulls away from football, 40-21

The University of Dayton Flyers came from behind three times to take leads, but Southeast Missouri scored the last three touchdowns of the contest in the game's final 12 minutes to pull away 40-21 Saturday afternoon in Cape Girardeau, Mo.

WilmerHale Dogs of Fall Adoption Fest

Find a new furry friend on September 22nd at the annual “WilmerHale Dogs of Fall Adoption Fest!”

Comprehensive ABA report offers tips, roadmap for states working to improve access to justice

A new report by the American Bar Association provides a first-of-its-kind look at access to justice commissions nationwide, offering an in-depth analysis of their structures, activities, staffing and funding as well as best-practice recommendations.

BWC awards $426,000 in grants to protect Ohio firefighters

Forty Ohio fire departments will share $426,000 in grants from the Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation (BWC) under a program to protect firefighters from carcinogens and other harmful health hazards encountered by firefighters during their daily work activities.

Student achievement increases seen statewide in 2018 Ohio School Report Cards

The Ohio Department of Education recently released the annual Ohio School Report Cards and, once again, student achievement increased statewide in multiple areas — and with most subgroups of students.