Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Supreme Court of Ohio denies company’s tax exemption for natural gas use


Supreme Court of Ohio denies company’s tax exemption for natural gas use

Dan Trevas, Supreme Court of Ohio

The Ohio Supreme Court recently rejected a Portage County company’s exemption from paying use taxes on natural gas to heat the six buildings where custom aluminum truck trailers are made.

The Supreme Court affirmed an Ohio Board of Tax Appeals (BTA) decision upholding the Ohio tax commissioner’s 2009 assessment of East Manufacturing Corp. The tax commissioner audited the company for a three-year period starting in 2003, and found its natural gas suppliers never collected use taxes. The company conceded that about 8 percent of its six buildings were used for administrative purposes and the gas for that area should be taxed. But it maintained that the rest of the 382,240 square feet of indoor manufacturing space should be exempt.

Writing for the Court majority, Justice Mary DeGenaro ruled East could not claim the exemption for gas used to regulate the environment in a “special and limited area” for its entire manufacturing space, or seek the exemption for gas “used in the manufacturing operation” for most of the facility.

Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor and Justices Terrence O’Donnell, Sharon L. Kennedy, Judith L. French, and R. Patrick DeWine joined the opinion. Justice Patrick F. Fischer concurred in judgment only.

Temperature Regulation Essential, Company Argued

Only one of East’s six manufacturing buildings had interior walls. One wall separated the administrative offices from the assembly area. The company used the open internal spaces to better accommodate the movement of the large truck attachments it fabricates.

While the company did not have use taxes withheld and remitted by its natural gas suppliers, the tax commissioner’s audit found that only two portions of the gas, used for painting operations and welding systems, could be exempt. East appealed the decision to the BTA.

At the BTA, the company argued that about 92 percent of the natural gas assessment should be exempt because it was essential to maintain the temperature of the buildings at 50 degrees or higher. The company explained the high amount of welding that takes place in the manufacturing process and that maintaining that temperature was necessary to prevent condensation, which could harm the welds.

The tax commissioner cited the guide for aluminum welding that East used and pointed to material in the guide contradicting East’s argument that a 50-degree temperature is needed to meet industrial needs. The BTA affirmed the assessment and found that the company failed to establish how the disputed natural gas use could qualify for an exemption. East appealed the decision to the Ohio Supreme Court, which at the time was required to hear the case.

Tax Applies, Court Ruled

The majority opinion states that under R.C. 5739.02 every sale or use of “tangible personal property” is presumably taxable. The law provides several exemptions, and East presented three theories as to why its gas use was entitled to an exemption.

The company argued that under R.C. 5739.02(B)(42)(g) the tax does not apply to the “use of things transferred” that are primarily used in the manufacturing operation to produce personal property for sale. One of East’s arguments was that natural gas supply qualified under R.C. 5739.011(C)(5) because the gas was a thing transferred “that totally regulates the environment in a special and limited area of the manufacturing facility where the regulation is essential for the production to occur.”

The Court noted that, under R.C. 5739.011(C)(5), the exemption is generally not permitted for gas used to regulate temperature and cited state tax rules that explain the only exception is for areas such as clean rooms and paint booths where specific environmental conditions are essential for production. The BTA determined that heating the entire plant is not a temperature control focused on a special and limited area and thus does not meet that exception. Among other reasons, the company argued it regulated a special and limited area because only its manufacturing buildings, and not its entire property including the outdoor area, are heated with gas and kept at an expected temperature.

“But equating ‘special and limited area’ with ‘indoors’ would result in the exception swallowing the general rule that the ‘thing transferred’ for temperature regulation is taxable and would defeat the restrictive effect of the statutory language,” the opinion stated.

The Court stated the exemption specifically excludes property to regulate temperature and cannot be considered “used in the manufacturing operation.”

Because the natural gas was specifically excluded from the exemption under R.C. 5739.011(C)(5), the Court rejected alternative arguments East made related to the use of gas in the manufacturing process and found the BTA’s position to be “lawful and reasonable.”

2017-0666. E. Mfg. Corp. v. Testa, Slip Opinion No. 2018-Ohio-2923.

The opinion can be found online at:

Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.

Date Published: August 17, 2018


Supreme Court of Ohio


Montgomery County Clerk of Commission retiring after 30 years of dedicated service

Montgomery County Clerk of Commission, Gayle Ingram, has retired after a 30-year career in public service. Ingram was appointed Clerk of Commission in 2010 after serving as Manager of Commission Services and Deputy Clerk for the Montgomery County Board of County Commissioners. She began her career in public service back in 1979 with the Miami Valley Regional Planning Commission and went on to serve in roles with New Futures for Dayton Area Youth, Inc. and the Office of Family and Children First.

University of Dayton football opened preseason camp Sunday

University of Dayton head football coach Rick Chamberlin and his staff welcomed 114 players back to campus Sunday, August 5 as the Flyers prepare for the 2018 football season. UD opens the season at home vs, Robert Morris on Sept. 1.

Annual 2018: Why women leave the law—and what we can do about it

The issue of women leaving the practice of law at what should be the height of their careers, and what can be done about it was the focus of one of ABA President Hilarie Bass’ initiatives. At the ABA Annual Meeting in Chicago, the “Long-Term Careers for Women in Law: What’s Pushing Women Out and What Can We Do to Keep Them in the Profession?” program laid out what a year’s worth of scientific research has revealed about the dilemma.

Report: Despite evolving technology, Ohio still a manufacturing powerhouse

Manufacturing continues to be a significant sector for Ohio - including Franklin County, according to a new report from the Ohio Manufacturers' Association.

Chinese national living in Massachusetts pleaded guilty to distributing opioids and other drugs that were shipped from China to the U.S. and ultimately to Ohio

A Chinese national who had been living in Massachusetts pleaded guilty to distributing opioids and other drugs that were shipped from China to the United States and ultimately to Ohio.

Supreme Court of Ohio suspends lawyer for profanity-laced abuse of paralegal

A Cleveland lawyer’s paralegal repeatedly recorded conversations of her boss berating her physical appearance and dress, and calling her a “ho,” “dirtbag,” and other obscenities. The lawyer’s explanation for his behavior was that he learned the lingo from rappers and hip-hop artists he represents as an entertainment lawyer, and he thought he was being funny.

Ponzi scheme victims cannot sue brokers who sent funds to perpetrator

Ohio law does not allow victims of an alleged Dayton Ponzi scheme to seek financial recovery from brokers that unknowingly purchased fraudulent investments from the scam perpetrator at the direction of the victims, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled recently.

A year after fatal State Fair ride accident, legislation still under discussion

As Ohio fair season continues throughout the summer and early fall, lawmakers in the Ohio House of Representatives have unfinished business relating to a bill that aims to beef up amusement ride safety, in the opinion of one of their own.

Report shows that stricter land regulations contribute to higher home prices

With stricter land-use regulations, homeowners can expect higher home values and strong job growth, according to a new report.

Bill aimed to protect people's due process

Upon return from summer recess, lawmakers seated for a committee in the Ohio House of Representatives may consider a piece of legislation meant to correct officially a public record.

Twelve charged in moving company scams

Law enforcement asks potential additional victims to call or email hotline

Bill launched by Attorney General’s CyberOhio Initiative signed into law

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine today released the following statement regarding Senate Bill 220, the Data Protection Act sponsored by State Senators Bob Hackett (R-London) and Kevin Bacon (R-Westerville) being signed into law:

Supreme Court of Ohio dismisses violations against attorney who represented man he never met

The Ohio Supreme Court recently dismissed rule violation charges against a Cleveland attorney who filed and lost the criminal conviction appeal of man he never met or spoke to until after the case ended.

Therapy dog’s ‘pawsitive’ influence on drug court participants noticeable

Facing a judge can be intimidating. But in Summit County, there’s a new probation officer who provides some hand holding, at least with his paws.

August is national immunization month

August is National Immunization Month and Public Health – Dayton & Montgomery County is reminding parents to have their school-age children vaccinated.

Dayton athletics hosts YMCA Olympics

The University of Dayton partnered with the YMCA to host the twelfth annual YMCA Olympics.

Final defendants sentenced in pharmacy robberies case

The final two of eight defendants were sentenced in U.S. District Court today for their roles in pharmacy robberies in Fairfield, Middletown, Franklin, Hamilton, Westerville, Trotwood, Dayton, Oakwood, Kettering, Beavercreek, Moraine, Vandalia, Union Township and Cincinnati.

Fiona the Hippo book launch party

The Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden is thrilled to invite children of all ages to the launch party of the latest book about its most famous resident, Fiona the hippo, on August 7, 2018. Published by Zonderkidz, the children’s division of Zondervan, Fiona the Hippo features charming artwork from New York Times bestselling illustrator and Cincinnati native, Richard Cowdrey.

Mid-Atlantic Forest Fire Compact wins National Smokey Bear award

The Mid-Atlantic Interstate Forest Fire Protection Compact’s (MAIFFPC) Fire Prevention Committee was recently presented with the Golden Smokey Award, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR). Ohio’s representative on the committee, Aaron Kloss of Centerburg in Knox County, accepted the honor on behalf of the ODNR Division of Forestry. The presentation ceremony took place at Vinton Furnace State Forest on Wednesday in conjunction with the Northeast-Midwest State Foresters Alliance summer meeting.

Montgomery County innovative program receives prestigious state award

Montgomery County’s “Trucks and Tomatoes” Job Training and Urban Garden Enhancement Project is the recipient of the 2018 President’s Award for Innovative Practices by the Ohio Conference on Community Development.