Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Half-baked? The Supreme Court decision on Masterpiece Cakeshop

 

Half-baked? The Supreme Court decision on Masterpiece Cakeshop

Lata Nott, First Amendment Center

The U.S. Supreme Court decided to “punt” earlier this week on one of its most controversial cases of the year, Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission — choosing a narrow legal rationale rather than the larger issue weighing laws on discrimination versus freedom of religion.

In doing so, the court made “moot” many of the countless arguments, think pieces, and debates about how the Court’s decision might reshape the landscape of gay rights and religious freedom in the United States.

To recap: In 2012, Jack Phillips, owner of the Masterpiece Cakeshop, refused to bake a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, stating that same-sex weddings were antithetical to his religious beliefs. The couple filed a complaint with the Colorado Civil Rights Commission, which found that Phillips’s repeated refusal to make cakes for same-sex weddings was a violation of Colorado’s Anti-Discrimination Act. The Commission was unswayed by Phillips’s argument that requiring him to make these wedding cakes would violate his First Amendment rights. Phillips appealed to the Colorado Court of Appeals, which sided with the Commission.

The Supreme Court’s decision to review Phillips’s case sparked anxieties across the political spectrum. Some feared that the Court would find current civil rights laws unconstitutional, and wondered if that would effectively transform the freedom of religion into the freedom to discriminate. Others worried that a decision against Phillips would undermine religious freedom — could laws like the Anti-Discrimination Act force people to act against their consciences? Adding another wrinkle, many First Amendment advocates found the larger issue to be about speech rather than religion — does the creation of a custom wedding cake count as an act of speech (in which case, you should not be compelled to make one against your will)?

The Supreme Court’s opinion neatly sidestepped all of these questions. It narrowed its focus to how the Colorado Civil Rights Commission made its original judgment against Phillips, and found that the Commission acted with hostility towards religion in its deliberations. Freedom of religion requires the government to stay neutral on matters of religion, neither promoting nor undermining any particular religion or religion in general. The Court found a commissioner’s statement that “religion has been used to justify all kinds of discrimination throughout history, whether it be slavery, whether it be the Holocaust,” and description of this as, “one of the most despicable pieces of rhetoric that people can use,” to be disparaging toward religion in general and Phillips’s religion in particular.

So where does that leave us? Almost exactly where we were before. Colorado’s Anti-Discrimination Act, and laws like it, are still constitutional. Freedom of religion could still be a possible loophole to avoid compliance with such laws. A custom-made cake may or may not be an act of speech. Civil rights commissioners should watch the tone of their deliberations.

But just as the Supreme Court has been deliberating this case for the past few months, so has the American public. Early results from our 2018 State of the First Amendment Survey show that 54.5 percent of Americans disagree that the Masterpiece Cakeshop should have a legal obligation to create a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, while 42 percent think that it should. The survey respondents were slightly more likely to side with the Masterpiece Cakeshop if the question was framed as a freedom of religion issue rather than a freedom of speech issue. Any way you slice it, this is still a very divisive issue for the American public. The Supreme Court’s decision is unlikely to completely satisfy anyone, but also leaves hope for both sides in the future. A classic example of having your cake and, yes, eating it too.

Lata Nott is executive director of the First Amendment Center of the Freedom Forum Institute. Contact her via email at lnott@newseum.org, or follow her on Twitter at @LataNott.

Date Published: June 22, 2018

 

First Amendment Center

 

Hundreds arrested, dozens of firearms seized, 60 kilograms of cocaine and five kilograms of heroin seized as part of "Operation We Are CLE"

The U.S. Marshals Service and Drug Enforcement Administration, working with federal, state and local law enforcement agencies, recently completed the first phase of “Operation We Are CLE,” resulting in the arrests of more than 200 people, confiscation of 36 firearms and seizure of 60 kilograms of cocaine and nearly five kilograms of heroin in Cleveland.

Older adults are at higher risk for complications from extreme heat

The Ohio Department of Aging reminds all Ohioans to treat hot temperatures and high humidity levels as severe weather. As we age our bodies may become less able to adapt to extreme conditions. In addition, older adults are more likely to have chronic health conditions that can upset normal body responses to heat, like sweating. With more health issues can also come more prescription medicines, which can also impair our bodies’ ability to regulate temperature.

Access to birth control, education hallmarks of Prevention First bill

A bill intended to curb unplanned pregnancies and indirectly reduce the state's high infant mortality rate was the subject of a recent hearing before lawmakers in the Ohio House of Representatives.

Ohio ranked in the middle of the pack in new economic report

Ohio's economy placed near the middle when compared with the other 49 states and the nation's capital.

Bill would allow municipal tax to pay for dental care for at-risk children

A Cleveland Democrat pitched a legislative measure to allow Ohio municipalities to levy a tax for the purposes of covering costs of dental health of a city's most vulnerable residents.

Supreme Court of Ohio considers prosecutorial opposition to new trial for man sentenced to death for murder

The Ohio Supreme Court on Tuesday, June 26th, heard four oral arguments, including a challenge by the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s Office of the new trial ordered for Anthony Apanovitch who was sentenced to death for the 1984 murder and rape of a Cleveland woman.

Residents of Ohio’s nursing homes and assisted living facilities rate their providers

The Office of the State Long-Term Care Ombudsman, a division of the Ohio Department of Aging, has released results of the 2017 Long-Term Care Resident Satisfaction Survey. The survey, conducted through face-to-face interviews with residents of nursing homes and residential care (assisted living) facilities, gauges residents’ satisfaction with an array of focus areas related to their care and everyday life.

Lawmaker comes up with 'AWFUL' plan for legislator pay adjustments

A Cincinnati Republican recently proposed a method to adjust legislators' pay that would alleviate the need for lawmakers themselves to do the math.

Attorney General DeWine announces $100 million multistate settlement with Citibank over Libor manipulation

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine, along with 41 other attorneys general, recently announced a $100 million settlement with Citibank for fraudulent conduct involving the London interbank offered rate, or Libor, a key interest rate with widespread impact on global markets.

Supreme Court of Ohio considers disciplinary action against attorney who accused judges of incompetence

The Ohio Supreme Court on Tuesday, June 26th, heard four oral arguments, including an issue brought by the Ohio Board of Professional Conduct which is recommending a one-year suspension with six months stayed for Cleveland attorney Richard A. Oviatt. According to the board’s report, the attorney “impugned the integrity of the judges from the Eighth District Court of Appeals by accusing them of incompetence, corruption, and criminal conduct.”

Author of state health care transparency law offers revision

The southwest Ohio lawmaker who devised the Ohio Price Transparency Law in 2015 has proposed a new version of the law, making health insurance companies responsible for estimates of health care costs rather than physicians - as originally enacted.

Attorney General DeWine announces six arrests following seizure of $3.4 million in cocaine

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and members of the Central Ohio Organized Crime Investigations Commission/High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area (HIDTA) Task Force announced recently the arrests of six people following the seizure of approximately 75 pounds of cocaine.

Ohio Department of Education celebrates new graduates headed to U.S. military

In a first-ever ceremony held at The Ohio State University, the Ohio Department of Education recently celebrated the members of the class of 2018 who are joining the U.S. military.

Men arrested in connection with 20-pound fentanyl seizure charged federally

Four men have been charged federally in a case involving the seizure of approximately 20 pounds of fentanyl.

Freedom Celebration 2018 –with featured guest, Sebastian Gorka

First Grace of Dayton, Ohio will host its 30th anniversary Freedom Celebration, Sunday July 8th. This year’s Freedom Celebration 2018 will feature a keynote address by Dr. Sebastian Gorka, former Deputy Assistant National Security Advisor to President Donald J Trump and NY Times best-selling author of Defeating Jihad; The Winnable War. Dr. Gorka has just returned from Singapore, where he was a witness to the historic, landmark U.S.-North Korea Summit and he will be sharing observations concerning this agreement and its implications for our own national security. Sebastian Gorka is uniquely qualified to speak to issues of national security and American freedom as he shares his own story of fleeing the oppression of communism as a child and legally immigrating to the U.S., where he rose to the pinnacle of power and influence as an advisor to the President in the White House! He will be introducing his brand new book, (which is set for release on September 25, 2018), Why We Fight: Recovering America’s Will to Win at the Freedom Celebration.

Three Raiders drafted in the annual MLB Draft

Three Raiders drafted in the annual MLB Draft: Matt Morrow signs with Pirates; Ryan Weiss signs with Diamondbacks; Caleb Sampen signs with Dodgers.

Wright State expects to post multimillion-dollar budget surpluses after years of deficits

Emerging from years of overspending and budget deficits, Wright State will post a $7.2 million budget surplus this year and has crafted a fiscal 2019 budget with a $3 million surplus that earmarks funds for strategic investments to bolster tuition revenue and build the university’s future.

The Ohio State Bar Foundation inducts new members into fellows program

OSBF welcomes 32 attorneys to its efforts to advance the law and build a better justice system

Man indicted for selling heroin that resulted in fatal overdose

A Toledo man was indicted in federal court for selling heroin that resulted in a fatal overdose last year, said U.S. Attorney Justin E. Herdman and FBI Special Agent in Charge Stephen D. Anthony.

Pro Bono hours reported increases in Ohio

The number of pro bono hours provided by attorneys to low-income Ohioans has gone up.