Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News ‘Spoliation of evidence” claims require proof that evidence destroyed


‘Spoliation of evidence” claims require proof that evidence destroyed

Dan Trevas, Supreme Court of Ohio

Ohio is among a small number of states that recognize civil causes of action for intentional spoliation of evidence, but the actions are limited to evidence that was physically destroyed, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled recently.

The Supreme Court unanimously rejected former Warren City School District employee Kristen Elliott-Thomas’ claim that the tort of spoliation of evidence applied to her case against two attorneys representing the district. She alleged the two intentionally withheld and hid evidence she needed to pursue a wrongful termination and sex discrimination suit against the district.

Writing for the Court majority, Justice Sharon L. Kennedy stated the Court had several reasons not to expand the scope of “spoliation of evidence” to included interfering with or concealing evidence, including the concern that juries would have difficulty assessing the harm of those acts. She also wrote there are other means to “deter and punish interference with and concealment of evidence by parties and counsel.”

Justices Terrence O’Donnell, Judith L. French, Patrick F. Fischer, and R. Patrick DeWine joined Justice Kennedy’s opinion, as did First District Court of Appeals Judge Russell Mock, sitting for former Justice William M. O’Neill.

Justice Fischer also wrote a concurring opinion where he addressed potential concerns that the decision could deprive some parties of an adequate legal remedy when concealment or interference is discovered after a case has concluded. He noted that was not at issue in Elliott-Thomas’ lawsuit, in which Elliott-Thomas learned of the alleged spoliation during the pendency of her wrongful termination case.

Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor concurred in judgment only.

School Employee Fights Firing

Elliott-Thomas sued the Warren City schools, its board of education and five school board members, in 2012. Attorneys David K. Smith and David Hirt represented the district and the board members in the wrongful termination case.

While the case was pending, Elliott-Thomas filed a separate lawsuit against Smith, Hirt, and two board members, alleging the intentional spoliation of evidence. The lawyers asked the trial court for summary judgment in their favor, arguing that Elliott-Thomas failed to prove that Smith or Hirt physically destroyed evidence. The trial court agreed, and dismissed the case, noting that Elliott-Thomas’ allegations amounted to an evidence discovery dispute in her wrongful termination case and the parties should address the dispute in that case.

Elliott-Thomas appealed to the Eleventh District Court of Appeals, which reversed the trial court. The Eleventh District concluded that a viable spoliation claim does not require proof that the evidence was physically destroyed, and could go forward if Elliott-Thomas could prove there was “intentional concealment, interference with, or misrepresentation of evidence.” The district’s attorneys noted the decision conflicted with rulings of other appeals courts, including the Fifth District. The Eleventh District submitted the case to the Supreme Court to resolve the differences.

Destruction Requirement Disputed

The Ohio Supreme Court addressed the issue of intentional spoliation of evidence in its 1993 Smith v. Howard Johnson Co. Inc. case. Justice Kennedy explained in that case, the Court established that the tort has five elements:

There is pending or probable pending litigation involving the plaintiff

The defendant knows the litigation is pending or probable

The defendant willfully destroyed evidence designed to disrupt the plaintiff’s case

The plaintiff’s case was disrupted

The defendant’s action resulted in damages to the plaintiff.

Elliott-Thomas argued to the Court that while the Smith decision required willful destruction, the Court did not limit the requirement to only physical destruction. She pointed to other cases where claims of intentional concealment and interference were sufficient for the case to proceed.

The opinion stated the Court was not convinced the cases Elliott-Thomas cited supported her theory and noted that several Ohio appellate courts have concluded the intentional concealment or interference with evidence are not included in an intentional spoliation claim. The Court majority also found that none of the other state supreme courts that recognize an intentional spoliation claim have defined the claim to include concealment or interference.

The opinion noted that most states have declined to adopt a cause of action for intentional spoliation. The Court majority found guidance in the reasons and principles discussed by these courts in rejecting an expansion of the cause of action to encompass intentional concealment or interference.

Other Remedies Available

The opinion stated one reason to find that the cause is limited only to physical destruction is that other remedies exist when a party conceals or interferes with the production of evidence. It noted that in the Ohio Rules for Civil Procedure — rule Civ.R. 37 — trial courts are empowered with broad discretion to impose sanctions on parties who violate the discovery rules by concealing or interfering with evidence. And the Ohio Rules of Professional Conduct, including Prof. Cond. R. 3.3 and 3.4, subjects lawyers to disciplinary actions for violating discovery rules.

The Court reversed the Eleventh District’s decision and reinstated the trial court’s judgment in favor of the district and board members.

2017-0693. Elliott-Thomas v. Smith, Slip Opinion No. 2018-Ohio-1783.

The opinion can be viewed online at:

Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.

Date Published: May 22, 2018


Supreme Court of Ohio


Supreme Court of Court affirms death sentence for teen’s murderer

The Ohio Supreme Court took into account the fact that a man who plotted to rob and kill a childhood friend had just turned 19 years old at the time of the murder, but that was not enough to reverse the death penalty he received from a Warren County court.

Lawmakers mull local self-defense statutes

House lawmakers recently considered further testimony both for and against a bill that would codify an affirmative claim of self defense for Ohioans who own and use guns.

State hires law firm to remove sealed records faster for background checks

The state of Ohio has hired a law firm to remove former offenders' sealed criminal records from background check company databases faster.

If it can rain, it can flood: Why flood insurance is a wise bet for homeowners

(BPT) The federal government considers floods the nation's most common natural disaster. They strike every state and leave homeowners with huge repair costs. Why? Because typical homeowners insurance doesn't cover flood damage.

Common Good: Mental health and criminal justice

More than 383,000 adults with serious mental illnesses are being held in a U.S. jail or prison, according to the nonprofit Treatment Advocacy Center. Of the 64,000 people jailed or imprisoned in Ohio in 2005, more than 10,000 were estimated to have serious mental illnesses.

SBA partners with veterans employment program

The U.S. Small Business Administration announced this week a partnership with the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs to give service members access to self-employment assistance to kickstart any untapped entrepreneurial spirit in the ranks of American heroes.

State lawmakers move to make 'spoofing' phone numbers illegal

Lawmakers keen on quashing the practice of manipulating parts of or entire phone numbers to obfuscate the caller's identity for purposes of defrauding the call recipient are expected to consider a bill that would make the trick a criminal offense.

Bond issue proposed to attack toxic algae blooms

A pair of state lawmakers whose districts abut Lake Erie recently proposed a solution to the dangerous algae blooms that take over swaths of the state's Great Lake each summer.

Trucker and 10 others convicted for cheating BWC

Agency owed more than $500,000 in restitution

Ohio Wildlife Council approves 2018-2019 hunting regulations

The 2018-2019 hunting and trapping seasons were among the regulations approved by the Ohio Wildlife Council at its scheduled meeting on Thursday, May 17, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR).

Prevention and self-management can ensure healthy lives with chronic conditions

The Ohio Department of Aging works every day to provide resources for individuals and communities to help our elders live as independently as possible, for as long as possible, in the settings they prefer. As we age, many of us will develop chronic conditions, such as diabetes, heart disease or arthritis, and with the right supports, we can continue to thrive.

Report finds nearly 60,000 ohioans homeless in 2016

The Ohio Human Services Data Warehouse (OHSDW) has released the first in a series of groundbreaking reports exposing the troubling extent of Ohio's homelessness crisis. It finds that 58,484 Ohioans received homeless services in 2016 from seven of Ohio's nine Continuum of Care (CoCs) organizations; that's more than the entire population of Vinton, Monroe, Noble and Morgan counties combined.

Columbus gets contradictory reports on people moving there

Recent studies offer a mix perspective on central Ohio migration.

CAANE Elder Celebration - June 7, 2018

Local seniors are invited to attend a day of workshops and gain information about healthy lifestyles and how to protect themselves against abuse, neglect and exploitation. The CAANE Elder Celebration will be held Thursday, June 7, from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. at the Trotwood YMCA (506 E. Main St., Trotwood OH 45426).

County Commissioners to appoint Michael Colbert as County Administrator

Montgomery County Commissioners Judy Dodge, Dan Foley and Debbie Lieberman have announced the selection of Michael Colbert as the next Montgomery County Administrator. Colbert is currently Assistant County Administrator – Development Services and oversees Workforce and Economic Development. He will replace Joe Tuss who is retiring at the end of August.

Progress report - Justice Committee for the Montgomery County jail

Thirteen months ago, in response to numerous lawsuits brought against Montgomery County for alleged abuses, the Montgomery County Commissioners and the County Sheriff jointly selected citizens to form a non-partisan Justice Committee charged over two years to review and analyze the strengths, weaknesses and challenges of the jail, and to provide the Sheriff and County Commissioners with recommendations for improvements. The committee is acutely aware that the community is waiting impatiently for its report. This process required a great deal of education about the jail for the committee members. The committee is now offering this progress report after its first year of work.

The Cincinnati Zoo Academy

The Cincinnati Zoo Academy has been a part of the public school system in Cincinnati since 1975. In 1995, the program underwent a substantial change from a strictly vocational program with an emphasis on natural resources and wildlife management to a four year college preparatory program where the students earn vocational degrees by working with zoo keepers for two hours a day. During the 2008 – 2009 school year we initiated a transition and became a Tech Prep program with articulation agreements with UC Blue Ash and Cincinnati State. Students spend their ninth and tenth grade years at the Hughes High School. During their eleventh and twelfth grade years they will spend part of each day at the Zoo Academy on zoo grounds.

University of Dayton to host Antioch writers’ summer workshop

Sharpen your writing and leadership skills at the Antioch Writers Summer Workshop and Center for Leadership events.

WSU softball falls in semi-finals

The Wright State softball team fell in the semifinals of the Horizon League Tournament last weekend, losing 2-1 at the hands of Oakland University.

Cleveland man pleads guilty to stealing $77,000 in federal grants designed to help Native Americans

A Cleveland man pleaded guilty to stealing more than $77,000 in federal grants designed to help Native Americans.