Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News OSBA Litigation Section awards Best Brief honors


OSBA Litigation Section awards Best Brief honors

Litigation Section of the Ohio State Bar Association (OSBA) recently announced the winners of the second annual Best Briefs Awards. These awards recognize four outstanding briefs filed in the Ohio Supreme Court, two drafted by private firms and two drafted by public offices.

The offices of Ohio Attorney General and the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor took top honors for the best public briefs while the winners from private firms were from the law offices of Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur, LLP and Organ Cole, LLP.

"I commend the OSBA Litigation Section for its work to promote collegiality in the profession and to highlight outstanding appellate advocacy in Ohio," said OSBA President Randall Comer. "Congratulations to all this year's honorees – their briefs are a must-read for law students, members of the Bar and all those interested in the art of rhetoric."

The briefs were selected from among those filed with the Ohio Supreme Court during 2016. Offices and firms were permitted to submit up to three briefs from any stage of litigation which were judged on the basis of marshalling authorities and facts, organization, clarity of writing and persuasiveness. Private brief submissions were judged by members of public offices and public briefs were evaluated by attorneys at private firms. The awards will be presented at the OSBA Litigation Section meeting at the All-Ohio Legal Forum on Aug. 23, 2018 at the Hilton Easton.

"We had a fantastic slate of briefs submitted for the competition," Vincent Holzhall, Chair of the OSBA Litigation Section said. "Our winners are a beacon of appellate advocacy at the highest level and a tribute to the Bar in Ohio."

Best Public Briefs

This is the second year that attorneys with the Ohio Attorney General's Office drafted one of the best public briefs, taking home honors for a filing in Ferguson v. State, defending a statute about employer consent to employee dismissals in workers' compensation appeals. State Solicitor Eric Murphy and Chief Deputy Solicitor in the Appeals Section of the Attorney General's office Michael Hendershot were the primary authors.

Assistant Prosecuting Attorney for the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office Anthony T. Miranda also won for his public brief filed in the case of State v. Mohamed. The brief secured a kidnapping conviction that had previously been reversed by the 8th District Court of Appeals.

Best Private Briefs

Ryan Sherman, a partner with Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur, LLP, was the primary author in a winning private brief filed in a case that successfully defended Sunoco Pipeline LP's exercise of eminent domain. Contributing authors included Chris Baronzzi, Kathleen Trafford and Brad Hughes.

Founding Partner of Organ Cole LLP Douglas R. Cole also won for his merit brief in the case of Johnson v. Montgomery, et al.The appeal concerned Ohio's Dram Shop Act and contributing authors included Erik J. Clark and David J. Twombly of Organ Cole, LLP and co-counsel Dennis Mulvihill and Stephen D. Behnke of Wright and Schulte, LLC.

Section Chair Holzhall also commended the judges of the competition, who reviewed a total of 27 submissions. "The efforts of our volunteer judges are greatly appreciated and their hard work on behalf of the Best Brief competition is wonderful," said Holzhall.

Public Brief Judges

John J. Kulewicz, Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease LLP

Douglas R. Cole, Organ Cole LLP

Lauren S. Kuley, Squire Patton Boggs

Kathleen M. Trafford, Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP

Irene C. Keyse-Walker, Tucker Ellis | LLP

Philip B. Sineneng, Thompson Hine

Paul W. Flowers, Paul W. Flowers Co., L.P.A.

Albert Lin, Ice Miller LLP

Thomas D. Warren, BakerHostetler

Rachel Bloomekatz, Gupta Wessler PLLC

Private Brief Judges

Michael J. Hendershot, Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine

Hannah C. Wilson, Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine

Evy M. Jarrett, Lucas County Prosecutor's Office

Ronald W. Springman, Jr., Hamilton County Prosecutor

Seth L. Gilbert, Franklin County Prosecuting Attorney

Andrew T. French, Montgomery County Prosecutor's Office

Bret S. Hammond, Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office

Craig M. Jaquith, Ohio Public Defender

Richard A. Cline Ohio Public Defender

Brooke M. Burns, Ohio Public Defender

Katherine E. Mullin, Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office

The OSBA Litigation Sections sponsors the Best Briefs Award in an effort to educate the bar, law students, and students generally about excellent written advocacy and to highlight appellate advocacy as a specialized practice.

Submissions for the 2018 Best Brief Awards are open from April 1 through June 1, 2018. Entries must be briefs filed in the Ohio Supreme Court in 2017 and can be submitted online at:

About the Ohio State Bar Association

The Ohio State Bar Association, founded in 1880, is a voluntary association representing approximately 26,000 members of the bench and bar of Ohio. Through its activities and the activities of its related organizations, the OSBA serves both its members and the public by promoting the highest standards in the practice of law and the administration of justice. The Litigation Section of the OSBA is comprised of legal professionals interested in all aspects of litigation practice. It provides a valuable forum for those members to interact and to share best practices, information and resources.

Date Published: April 20, 2018


Ohio State Bar Association


Three men plead guilty to concealing sending money to Anwar Al-Awlaki

Three men pleaded guilty to their roles in concealing the provision of thousands of dollars to Anwar Al-Awlaki in an effort to support violent jihad against U.S. military personnel in Iraq, Afghanistan and throughout the world.

Problem gambling: Know when to stop before you start

(BPT) The bright lights. The energy and laughter that fills the room. Casinos are fun and exciting to the vast majority of people but for some, they can be problematic.

Another substitute bill for affirmative self-defense proposal is proposed

A House committee recently adopted another substitute bill that further tinkers with legislation originally devised to codify an affirmative claim of self defense for Ohioans.

Some small steps can lead to businesses being more green

More companies are becoming more sustainable and eco-friendly each year.

Owner of payroll company indicted for stealing $914,000 from clients

A Putnam County woman was indicted on seven counts of bank fraud after she stole more than $900,000 from her clients, said U.S. Attorney Justin E. Herdman and FBI Special Agent in Charge Stephen D. Anthony.

Four people indicted for preparing hundreds of false tax returns

Four people from Ohio were named in a 31-count indictment for their roles in a conspiracy in which they filed more than 800 tax returns annually between 2012 and 2015 resulting in approximately $15 million in refunds being issued, a portion of which neither they nor their clients were entitled.

Let the power of compound interest help your 529 plan take off

If you’ve been to the movies, or watched a multitude of TV series recently, you’ve seen many, many superhero stories. These champions always stretch themselves to overcome obstacles and to come to others’ aid. There’s a superhero in the financial world as well, a college savings superhero – compound interest. Its super powers can really make your Ohio 529 college savings plan soar!

Assistance available to promote fruits, vegetables, flowers and nut crops in Ohio

State agriculture officials are looking forward to a new crop of specialty crop grant proposals in the coming weeks.

Bill designed to boost telemedicine in Ohio

Committee members in the Ohio House of Representatives took up a bill recently that would raise the profile of telemedicine services with regard to health benefit plans of Ohioans.

Naloxone rebate extended, more than $730,000 saved

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine announced recently that a rebate agreement that has saved Ohio agencies more than $730,000 on the cost of naloxone has been extended for another year.

Statewide dispute over traffic cameras continues at Supreme Court of Ohio

The Ohio Supreme Court on Tuesday, April 24th, heard four oral arguments, including a dispute between the state and the city of Toledo over traffic cameras.

Report: Ohio in top 10 for business growth

Ohio's year-over-year growth and new companies starting among 18 major industries last year placed it among the top 10 states for business creation.

Akron man and Barberton woman charged for defrauding insurance company

Two people were charged in federal court with mail fraud for defrauding an insurance company.

Ohio EPA updates findings on sources of nutrients impacting Ohio waters

As required by state legislation signed in 2015 (House Bill 64), Ohio EPA has completed its second statewide study identifying sources and estimating the annual amount of phosphorus and other nutrients flowing from the state’s watersheds into Lake Erie and the Ohio River. The study covers the Maumee, Portage, Sandusky, Vermilion, Cuyahoga, Great Miami, Scioto and Muskingum watersheds, and includes some direct tributaries to Lake Erie, which collectively represent surface water quality from 66 percent of the entire state.

Proposal would allow bystanders to sue police if an officer damages their smartphone

A Senate committee recently heard testimony of a Columbus lawmaker who wants to bolster protection of citizens’ free-speech rights as they pertain to recording the actions of law enforcement officers while on the job.

Tax breaks proposed for pro bono work

A bill proposing tax breaks for attorneys for pro bono legal services has gained little traction since its introduction in the Ohio House of Representatives nearly a year ago.

Attorney General DeWine announces applications now accepted for Teen Ambassador Board

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine recently announced that his office is now accepting applications for its Teen Ambassador Board.

New Albany man started making 3-D printed prosthetics in high school

Aaron Westbrook has gotten better tying his shoes with a single hand.

Housing authorities develop and operate low-income housing in Ohio

April 2018 was the 50th anniversary of National Fair Housing Month which celebrates the passage of the Fair Housing Act, signed into law by President Lyndon B. Johnson. The federal law was groundbreaking legislation and, half a decade later, public housing programs still work to eliminate discrimination and create equal opportunity in every community.

Dayton area tax preparer pleads guilty to filing false income tax returns with the IRS

David D. Hill, 34, of Dayton, Ohio, pleaded guilty to two counts of filing a false income tax return with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).