Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Man’s concurrent prison and community control sentences on separate offenses not improper


Man’s concurrent prison and community control sentences on separate offenses not improper

Dan Trevas, Supreme Court of Ohio

A judge’s decision to send a man to prison with a concurrent, but longer, period of community-control on a separate offense was appropriate, except for requiring his community-based confinement follow his prison time, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled recently.

In a unanimous opinion, the Supreme Court reversed an Eighth District Court of Appeals decision that vacated a portion of Michael T. Paige’s sentence. Writing for the Court, Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor stated the high court did not accept the Eighth District’s conclusion that the longer community control sentence resulted in an improper “split sentence.”

Eleventh District Court of Appeals Judge Cynthia W. Rice sat for former Justice William M. O’Neill.

Sentence Based on Violent Interaction with Girlfriend

In 2015, Paige pleaded guilty in Cuyahoga Common Pleas Court to one count each of sexual battery, abduction, and domestic violence, stemming from a violent encounter with his girlfriend. For sentencing purposes, the sexual battery and abduction counts were merged.

On the sexual battery charge, the trial court sentenced Paige to 42 months in prison followed by five years of postrelease control. On the domestic violence count, he was sentenced to five years of community control to run concurrently with the prison sentence on the sexual battery offense. The domestic violence sentence included several conditions, including that once released on the sexual battery count, Paige had to return to the county jail for an assessment and transfer to the county’s community-based correctional facility (CBCF). He also was required to complete an anger management program, was prohibited from having contact with the victim, and was classified as a Tier III sex offender.

Aspects of Sentence Challenged

Paige appealed his sentence to the Eighth District Court of Appeals, arguing the trial court violated the law by imposing a prison term and community control sanction that were to be served at the same time, and by imposing additional confinement in the CBCF after he completed his prison sentence. The Eighth District vacated the domestic violence sentence, and Cuyahoga County prosecutors appealed the case to the Supreme Court, which agreed to hear the case.

Court Sees Distinct Sentences, State Concedes Error

Chief Justice O’Connor explained that Ohio does not allow “split sentences.” For each felony offense, the law requires the trial court to impose either a prison term or a community control sanction, not both.

The Court stated that the trial court complied with the rule by imposing a prison sentence just for the sexual-battery count and a separate community control sentence for the domestic violence count. The Court wrote that merely because the community control sentence for the domestic violence conviction ran concurrently with the prison sentence for the separate sexual battery charge does not mean there was an improper split sentence.

The opinion noted that the state conceded the trial court erred when it ordered Paige’s placement in the CBCF after the prison term concluded. The Court stated that R.C. 2929.41(A) requires a “prison term, jail term, or sentence of imprisonment” to run concurrently, unless certain statutory exceptions apply. The Court noted that state law defines a term in a CBCF as “imprisonment,” which made the mandate that Paige spend time in a CBCF a “sentence of imprisonment” under the law, and none of the statutory exceptions to concurrent sentences of imprisonment applied here.

“Accordingly, the trial court had no statutory authority to order, as part of the community-control sanction, that Paige be placed in a CBCF after his completion of the separate prison term,” the opinion stated.

The Court reversed the Eighth District’s decision to vacate the entire sentence for Paige’s domestic violence charge. The justices vacated only the portion of the sentence requiring confinement in the CBCF and left the remaining conditions of the five-year community control sentence intact, including the required anger-management training and the no-contact-with-the-victim order.

2016-1848. State v. Paige, Slip Opinion No. 2018-Ohio-813.

A pdf of the opinion is available at:

Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.

Date Published: March 26, 2018


Supreme Court of Ohio


Check out the green (and gold) Raider Open House March 17

St. Patrick’s Day on Saturday, March 17, is the perfect day to visit Wright State University, whose school colors just happen to be green and gold. Raider Open House, held from 9 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., begins in the Student Union.

Enrollment in the University of Dayton School of Law's graduate program thriving

Enrollment in the University of Dayton School of Law's graduate program in government contracting and procurement has been more popular than anticipated since starting last summer, according to Dean Andy Strauss.

Second chance for four manatees following months of rehabilitation and care

Last week four rehabilitated manatees were returned to their natural waterways by SeaWorld Orlando, The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC), South Florida Museum, Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden, the Jacksonville Zoo and Gardens and Sea to Shore Alliance.

Sinclair bookstore celebrates Women's History Month

March is Women's History Month. To mark this event, Sinclair Bookstore is offering several titles for readers young and old at 25% OFF.

UD earns at-large bid in 2018 NCAA Tournament

The University of Dayton women's basketball team was selected to compete in the 2018 NCAA Division I women's basketball tournament with an at-large bid.

University of Dayton’s 16th annual Celebration of the Arts

Engineers make music. Mathematicians show their brushwork. And dancers take the stage. Nearly 250 University of Dayton students from almost every field of study will participate in the 16th annual Celebration of the Arts, an evening designed to bring the campus and greater Dayton community together through exhibits and performances.

WSU golf finishes at Cape Fear

The Wright State golf team finished seventh at the Cape Fear National Intercollegiate.

Electric cars were among highlights of this month’s Columbus Auto Show

The use of electric vehicles is slowly gaining traction around the country and those vehicles were among the highlights of this month’s Columbus International Auto Show.

Unintended consequences: MeToo may close doors previously open to women

As the MeToo movement continues its global circuit, a backlash seethes

Figuring out who businesses can sell their products or services to is not always simple

Businesses have the right to refuse service unless it crosses public accomodation laws from the federal to local level of U.S. government, but those instances are not often cut and dry, as demonstrated by several current high-profile court cases.

Congress tanks – but does it care?

We’re at a watershed moment in American political history. Our Congress — I’m talking about the people’s body, the institution created by our founders, and not just the men and women who currently inhabit it — is in deep trouble. And no one seems to be offering hope.

Man who used fake identity for 19 years pleads guilty to making a false statement on passport application

Fred Aundraus Gaston III, 44, of Cincinnati, pleaded guilty in U.S. District Court to a crime related to using a fake identity since 1999.

Hi-tech cars could lead to more cybersecurity issues

Cybersecurity is an issue across industries that deal with connected technologies. That includes the automotive industry as connected and autonomous vehicles are expected to be more common within the coming years.

Ohio Senate to consider guides for implementation of 5G wireless network

A committee in the Ohio Senate is expected to hear testimony in support of a revamped infrastructure bill meant to guide small cell tower placement on existing street lamps and utility poles in public rights-of-way.

OSU study: Teachers fail to report violence

A nationwide study tracking violence against teachers while at school found that one fifth of these victims fail to report the incidents to school administrators, researchers at the Ohio State University reported.

Shale oil production in Ohio slips, but natural gas increases

Oil production of Ohio's horizontal shale region is down while natural gas was up last year.

Airbnb and other rental properties

Innovative and very popular technologies and services have created new opportunities for real estate owners to generate income by renting their properties. Companies like Airbnb, Inc., Craigslist, Inc. and, Inc. now provide the opportunity to easily advertise houses, condominium units and other types of real property as available for temporary use online.

Former basketball coach owes school district almost $8k for botched fundraiser

A former basketball coach of the Northwest Local School District is on the hook for nearly $8,000 related to a fundraiser he mismanaged during 2016.

More indictments related to $2.1 million drug conspiracy

Five people were added to a now 39-count indictment for their roles in a conspiracy to distribute at least 220 pounds of marijuana and 345 pills of Oxycodone in Northeast Ohio, law enforcement officials said.

Seven indicted in eastern Ohio deer and turkey poaching case

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) recently announced the indictment of seven individuals who allegedly participated in a poaching enterprise that is suspected of illegally killing white-tailed deer and wild turkey. These crimes are alleged to have been committed from the years of 2006-2017.