Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Proposed bill would protect workers who forgo flu vaccination


Proposed bill would protect workers who forgo flu vaccination

KEITH ARNOLD, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

A bill meant to protect an individual's decision whether he should be vaccinated against the annual flu virus recently began a second round of hearings in the Ohio House of Representatives.

Filed as House Bill 193, the legislation relates directly to the decision and its impact on an employer's bottom line.

The bill would prohibit an employer from taking an adverse employment action against a person who has not been or will not be vaccinated against influenza.

"This legislation has been crafted after hearing the concerns of many Ohioans, health care professionals in particular, whose personal freedoms are being infringed upon as it relates to the ever increasing pressures and employment demands related to the influenza vaccination," Rep. Christina Hagan, R-Alliance, told members of the Health Committee. "HB 193 brings Ohio in line with 13 other states that prohibit the flu vaccine from being a mandatory term of employment."

The lawmaker was clear the legislation was neither pro-vaccine nor anti-vaccine.

Rather, the bill is about professionals maintaining their rights as individuals making their own medical decisions, specific to only the influenza vaccination.

Hagan said the issue was brought to her attention by a constituent medical professional whose relationship with an employer has been adversely affected by the individual's decision to waive flu vaccination.

"Many people, especially those who are in the business of keeping themselves and others healthy, do not want to inject strands of flu viruses into their system recognizing that the repercussions are not necessarily known nor are the positive intentions guaranteed," she said. "When this legislation was originally introduced, after the 2014-2015 flu season, the efficacy rate was at 23 percent; for populations under two and over 65 years of age the efficacy rates are even lower.

"This flu season, the efficacy rate is only 36 percent overall and more American's are finding themselves in outpatient care for influenza-like illnesses this year than in any other year."

Specifically, HB 193 would prohibit any employer, including the state and political subdivisions, from discharging without just cause, refusing to hire or from otherwise discriminating against any person with respect to hire, tenure, terms, conditions or privileges of employment on the basis that the person has not been or will not be vaccinated against influenza for any reason.

An amendment to the bill, however, would permit an employer to require an employee who has not or will not be vaccinated against influenza to comply with a reasonable alternative policy adopted by the employer to protect health and safety in the workplace.

"Voluntarily agreeing to take the flu vaccine, knowing the risks and low efficacy rate is a right that should be maintained, but to mandate such a vaccine or face termination of employment is an egregious violation of personal freedom," Hagan continued. "This legislation is necessary to preserve the autonomy of the individual.

"I am both pro-business and pro individual responsibility; I understand that there are substantial pressures on these medical institutions to increase rates of influenza vaccinations in correlation with their federal reimbursements."

The federal government, however, should not be deciding for the individual what is best for their individual healthcare situation, she said.

The lawmaker attributed the exposure to possible termination to "many respected professionals" having left jobs or switch careers altogether.

Ohio Legislative Service Commission analysis noted HB 193 did not establish any penalty for an employer who violates the prohibition.

The bill expressly notes legislators' intent that the prohibition not be expanded to include vaccination against any disease or illness other than influenza until the overwhelming scientific consensus clearly indicates a present and immediate danger to members of the public who receive the vaccination, analysis detailed.

Members of the Economic Development, Commerce and Labor Committee previously reported HB 193 out of committee last fall before referral to the Health Committee.

Seven fellow House members have signed on as cosponsors of the bill, which had not been scheduled a second hearing at time of publication.

Date Published: March 22, 2018


Copyright © 2018 The Daily Reporter - All Rights Reserved


Easterseals and Cincinnati Zoo foster developmental disability awareness year-round

March is Developmental Disability Awareness Month, but the partnership between Easterseals and the Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden builds awareness year-round. Since August 2017, the Zoo has been a work site for the Easterseals Work and Grow program, an initiative designed to provide a supportive transition to community-based employment for people with disabilities.

FOX Sports Ohio to air UD’s upcoming soccer match

FOX Sports Ohio will air the Saturday, March 24 exhibition match between the University of Dayton men's soccer team and professional soccer club FC Cincinnati.

Montgomery County meets or exceeds drinking water quality standards

Montgomery County Environmental Services has once again met or exceeded all drinking water safety and testing standards, as set forth by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Citizens can learn more by reading the 2018 Drinking Water Quality Report, which contains information about public safety and health, drinking water sources and water contaminant monitoring. The report is located at

Annual ArtsGala at Wright State

The annual Wright State University ArtsGala, which has raised more than $2.5 million for arts scholarships during its 18-year history, is scheduled for Saturday, March 24, with an impressive program featuring student performances in theatre, dance, motion pictures, music and visual arts.

Wright-Patt veterinary clinic caters to fur babies and furry warriors

The base veterinary clinic is open from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., Monday through Friday, to see the furry family members of active duty and retired veterans, as well as military working dogs.

Wright State’s season comes to an end

Picked to finish fifth in the Horizon League pre-season poll, the Wright State men's basketball team proved many outsiders wrong by advancing to the first round of the 2018 NCAA Tournament at the American Airlines Center in Dallas. The magical season ended on Thursday, March 15,with a 73-47 loss to the University of Tennessee.

Grand jury indicts six with charges related to murder

A federal grand jury has charged six individuals with crimes related to the August 2017 murder of Robert Caldwell in an indictment returned here recently. Two defendants are charged with death-penalty-eligible crimes.

Financially protect yourself for severe spring weather and flood damage

This is the perfect time to ensure you have adequate insurance for financial protection against damaging weather, said Ohio Department of Insurance Director Jillian Froment.

Dem plan would add BMV rolls to eligible juror lists

Juries that are more representative of the communities they are meant to typify is the rationale for a bill in the Ohio Senate that secured a first hearing earlier this week.

Save your green with Ohio’s 529 plan

Is green your favorite color? Ohio’s 529 Plan, CollegeAdvantage, wants to help you hold onto more of your green, especially when you’re saving it for your children’s future higher education costs. A 529 college savings plan has many benefits that can help.

Debate about whether to pay college athletes could play out in courtrooms

A debate between student-athletes and the organization governing them is coming to a head with the pay to play battle.

Bill would crack down on human trafficking practice of 're-homing' difficult or unwanted children

The Ohio House of Representatives has taken up legislation that addresses extrajudicial adoptions, perhaps the most pernicious form of human trafficking.

Creating a more eco-friendly, bill lowering home

(BPT) Instead of risking high energy bills in 2018, why not make a resolution that takes short-term effort but yields long-term benefits?

Attorney General DeWine announces arrests in human trafficking investigation

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and members of the Central Ohio Human Trafficking Task Force announced recently the arrests of four individuals accused of trafficking nearly a dozen women in the Columbus area.

Small banks, credit unions would get relief from reform bill

Separate from federal lawmakers' efforts to undo some of the damage the law known as Dodd-Frank has inflicted on smaller banks and credit unions, Ohio's Republican-led legislature is moving forward with its own plan to dismantle destructive elements of bank regulation.

New report: Life for immigrants in Ohio a mix of successes, challenges

Ohio's immigrants have achieved success in many facets of their lives, according to a new report, but challenges, such as financial hardship, still abound as they adjust to living in a new country.

Check out the green (and gold) Raider Open House March 17

St. Patrick’s Day on Saturday, March 17, is the perfect day to visit Wright State University, whose school colors just happen to be green and gold. Raider Open House, held from 9 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., begins in the Student Union.

Enrollment in the University of Dayton School of Law's graduate program thriving

Enrollment in the University of Dayton School of Law's graduate program in government contracting and procurement has been more popular than anticipated since starting last summer, according to Dean Andy Strauss.

Second chance for four manatees following months of rehabilitation and care

Last week four rehabilitated manatees were returned to their natural waterways by SeaWorld Orlando, The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC), South Florida Museum, Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden, the Jacksonville Zoo and Gardens and Sea to Shore Alliance.

Sinclair bookstore celebrates Women's History Month

March is Women's History Month. To mark this event, Sinclair Bookstore is offering several titles for readers young and old at 25% OFF.