Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Supreme Court of Ohio issues opinions in four cases

 

Supreme Court of Ohio issues opinions in four cases

Kathleen Maloney, Supreme Court of Ohio

Among the decisions released today, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled in four cases involving no-contest pleas, juveniles, or enhanced penalties for fentanyl possession.

No-Contest Pleas

A court cannot have a blanket policy of refusing to accept no contest pleas, the Supreme Court ruled.

“A trial court abuses its discretion when it rejects a no-contest plea as a matter of course without considering the facts and circumstances of the case,” Justice Judith L. French wrote in the Court’s opinion.

After being indicted for cocaine possession in Hamilton County, Andrea Beasley attempted to plead no contest. Because the court had a policy of rejecting no-contest pleas in all circumstances, Beasley pled guilty and was sentenced to three years of community control.

Although a valid guilty plea generally waives the right to appeal most pre-trial issues, Beasley’s plea did not amount to a waiver because Beasley’s attorney clearly stated in open court that Beasley wanted to plead no contest but could not because of the court’s policy, Justice French explained. Given that Beasley sufficiently preserved her objection, Beasley was permitted to appeal the trial court’s error.

The ruling returned the case to the trial court for Beasley to enter a new plea.

Justices Terrence O’Donnell, Sharon L. Kennedy, William M. O’Neill, and R. Patrick DeWine joined the opinion. The majority was also joined by Twelfth District Court of Appeals Judge Robert P. Ringland, sitting for Justice Patrick F. Fischer. Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor concurred in judgment only.

2016-1020. State v. Beasley, Slip Opinion No. 2018-Ohio-16.

A pdf of the opinion can be found online at: https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/2018/2018-Ohio-16.pdf

Parent’s Right to Counsel

The Supreme Court determined that a waiver of a parent’s right to counsel cannot be inferred by a parent’s unexplained failure to appear at a hearing involving the termination of parental rights. The Court directed the juvenile court in Franklin County to conduct a new permanent custody hearing for a child identified as R.K.

When R.K.’s mother, A.S., did not appear at a permanent custody hearing about her child, the juvenile court allowed A.S.’s attorney to withdraw from the case and granted permanent custody of the child to the county children’s services agency.

In the Court’s opinion, Justice O’Neill noted that A.S. was sent notification of the hearing, her attorney sent her a letter stating that she had to appear, she responded to the letter, and the attorney said he told the mother that, if she did not show up, the court would likely move forward with determining custody and he planned to withdraw as counsel. However, the juvenile court did not inquire about why A.S. was not there or where she was, the extent of their past attorney-client relationship, or her response to the attorney’s letter.

“We hold that when the state seeks to terminate a parent’s parental rights, the parent has the right to counsel. The parent cannot be deprived of that right unless the court finds that the parent has knowingly waived the right to counsel,” the opinion stated.

Chief Justice O’Connor joined the opinion.

Justice French concurred in the Court’s judgment and in the opinion’s syllabus. She wrote separately to offer additional guidance about when a parent waives his or her right to counsel. She stated that a trial court should review the totality of the circumstances; discuss on the record the factors indicating that a parent has waived the right to an attorney; and make a finding, based on the circumstances, that the parent waived the right. Justice Kennedy joined the concurring opinion.

Justice Fischer concurred only in the Court’s judgment.

Justice O’Donnell dissented, stating that A.S. waived her right to counsel because she received notice of the hearing date and time and a directive to attend, and she was told that, if she did not appear, the juvenile court would likely proceed and her attorney would withdraw from her case. Justice DeWine joined the dissent.

2017-0433. In re R.K., Slip Opinion No. 2018-Ohio-23.

A pdf of the opinion can be found online at: https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/2018/2018-Ohio-23.pdf

Juvenile Bindovers

A child whose case has been transferred by a juvenile court to adult court cannot appeal the bindover decision until adult court proceedings have concluded, the Supreme Court ruled.

The 17-year-old juvenile, identified as D.H., was charged with two robbery offenses in Montgomery County. The juvenile court determined that the youth was not amenable to rehabilitation and transferred jurisdiction over the cases to adult court. D.H. sought to immediately appeal the transfer orders.

In the majority opinion, Justice DeWine concluded that the bindover decision did not meet the definition of a final order that could be immediately appealed because D.H. would not lack a meaningful or effective remedy if he had to wait to appeal the transfer until after final judgment in the adult court.

“Here, the harm alleged in D.H.’s appeal — the transfer of his cases to adult court — can be rectified following final judgment,” the opinion stated. “The passage of time alone would not render an appeal following final judgment meaningless or ineffective.”

Justices Kennedy, French, and Fischer joined the opinion. Chief Justice O’Connor and Justice O’Donnell concurred only in the Court’s judgment.

Justice O’Neill dissented without a written opinion.

2016-1195 and 2016-1197. In re D.H., Slip Opinion No. 2018-Ohio-17.

A pdf of the opinion can be found online at: https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/2018/2018-Ohio-17.pdf

Fentanyl Dosage for Increased Penalties

Without a standard pharmaceutical reference manual that specifies for transdermal fentanyl the maximum daily dose in the usual dose range, as required by state law, possession of less than 20 grams of transdermal fentanyl is a fifth-degree felony, the Supreme Court concluded.

The Court reviewed a state law that enhances an aggravated drug possession offense from a fifth-degree felony to a second-degree felony if the amount of the drug “equals or exceeds five times the bulk amount but is less than fifty times the bulk amount.”

Mark H. Pountney stipulated that he knowingly obtained 10 three-day transdermal fentanyl patches. At trial in Cuyahoga County, a pharmacist for the state calculated the bulk amount of fentanyl based on the usual dosage range for morphine because the standard pharmaceutical reference manual he referenced did not include a usual dosage range for fentanyl patches.

However, in the Court’s unanimous opinion, Justice French wrote that the General Assembly decided to tie the meaning of “bulk amount” to information in pharmaceutical reference manuals and the statute requires that “the maximum daily dose in the usual dosage range” be specified in one of these manuals. Noting that the General Assembly is considering legislation about the escalation of penalties for fentanyl, the Court stated that “unless and until the General Assembly acts, our role is to apply the current statutory scheme as enacted.”

A pdf of the opinion can be found online at: https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/2018/2018-Ohio-22.pdf

Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.

Date Published: January 12, 2018

 

Supreme Court of Ohio

 

Report indicates conditions ripe for busy year of mergers, acquisitions

Research released recently shows that healthy financial conditions drive increased merger and acquisition activity within the middle market.

Kasich names poet laureate successor

A Cleveland Heights man has succeeded Ohio's first poet laureate to the honorary role that aims to highlight the literary art form.

Bill would enhance penalties for drug offenses near treatment centers

Ohio's opiate addiction and overdose problem has revealed perhaps the ugliest aspect of the illegal drug trade - the practice of preying on ex-users who seek rehabilitation.

Not-for-profit Bunker Labs Columbus helps veterans launch, grow businesses

In an effort to educate military veterans about what it takes to own a business, one Columbus company offers ways to empower those veterans to start and grow their startups.

5 tips for speed cleaning your home

(BPT) What is one of the biggest sources of stress? It's cleaning on a deadline, especially when guests are on their way.

Supreme Court of Ohio will hear three oral arguments today, including the appeal of a man on death row

The Ohio Supreme Court will hear three oral arguments today, including an appeal by Willie G. Wilks, Jr, who was sentenced to death in 2014 after being convicted of murder.

Five indicted for firearms violations

Five people were indicted for firearms violations, U.S. Attorney Justin E. Herdman said.

Sister convicted of retaliating against witness in brothers' trial

Joy McShan Edwards, 37, of Steubenville, was convicted in U.S. District Court recently of retaliation against a witness.

Retirement coaches can help prepare for post-career life

Planning for retirement? You may want to consider hiring a retirement coach.

Supreme Court of Ohio will hear three oral arguments today, including a consideration of whether concealing evidence constitutes spoliation

The Ohio Supreme Court will hear three oral arguments today, including an argument about whether the tort of intentional interference cover evidence that has been concealed.

ODNR Division of Wildlife introduces new K-9 program

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) is proud to announce that the ODNR Division of Wildlife is joining more than 20 states in the adoption of a wildlife K-9 program.

Chronic wasting disease confirmed in Ohio captive deer

No cases found in wild deer population; active steps taken to control further spread

Two pharmacy robbery defendants sentenced

Two Indianapolis men were sentenced recently in U.S. District Court for conspiring to rob a Middletown pharmacy of morphine and oxycodone on April 29, 2017 for the purpose of selling the drugs on the street.

Common tax mistakes to avoid in 2018

(BPT) Life changes - getting married, having a baby, buying or selling a home, sending a child off to college or retiring - often come with changes to your tax situation. Overlooking these changes when filing your taxes can lead taxpayers to make mistakes that leave money on the table, potentially impacting their refund at a time when the average refund is about $2,800. Here is a list of common tax mistakes to avoid in the 2018 filing season to help ensure you don't miss any deductions or credits that you deserve.

Think tank wants 'broader perspective' on regional economic study committee

A representative of the Greater Ohio Policy Center told Ohio Senate members that a bipartisan plan to create a regional economic study committee would be better served to include individuals from an advocacy group, an Ohio foundation and a representative of a metropolitan planning organization.

House members accept compromise bill for measure to limit special elections

Lawmakers seated for the Government Accountability and Oversight Committee in the Ohio House of Representatives reckoned recently that some August special elections are acceptable - just not those that amount to a permanent tax levy.

Supreme Court of Ohio heard oral arguments last week, including whether a wrongful death case involving a nursing home was wrongly sent to arbitration

The Ohio Supreme Court heard four oral arguments Tuesday, January 23rd, including a one debating whether a trial court improperly sent a wrongful death case to arbitration.

ODA encourages Ohioans to respond to census of agriculture now

The Ohio Department of Agriculture (ODA) urges Ohio farmers and producers who have not yet done so to respond to the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Census of Agriculture. Responses are accepted in the mail and online through February 5.

Two Brazilian nationals indicted after being arrested with credit card skimmers, 250 counterfeit credit or bank cards and nearly $140,000 in cash

Two Brazilian nationals were indicted after police arrested them with two credit card skimmers, more than 250 counterfeit credit or bank cards and nearly $140,000 in cash, law enforcement officials said.

5 strategies for protecting your valuables

(BPT) Home is your sanctuary, your castle, the place where you feel the most secure and protected. It is natural to feel this way. So, it is not surprising that you store your prized possessions and valuables at home as well. But is that the best choice for all your valuables?