Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Proposed bill that would disclose century-old records is genealogist's dream


Proposed bill that would disclose century-old records is genealogist's dream

KEITH ARNOLD, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

In the age of and 23andMe, consumer products that allow individuals to trace their family lineage and define their genetic make up, a proposal by lawmakers to make public records sealed for 100 years or more would aid in such endeavors.

"This is important information one would need to discover their family's heritage or the history of their region," a joint sponsor of the bill, Republican Rep. Rick Perales of Beavercreek, told lawmakers during sponsor testimony of House Bill 139.

Succinctly, the bill would eliminate the disclosure exemption for any permanently retained public record 100 years after the date of its creation, except for records protected by the attorney-client privilege and trial preparation records.

Such records include:


County home registers,

Children's home registers,

Juvenile court cases,

Witness dockets,

Lunacy records,

Inheritance tax records, and

Veterans' relief records.

"This legislation seeks to unseal these documents 100 years after the creation of the document," Perales said. "The sealed time period of 100 years takes into consideration any complications or emotional impact that opening these records might have for certain individuals since it allows the timespan of at least one generation to pass.

"This is similar to the federal policy to lift restrictions on United States census records after 72 years."

Galen Wilson, an archivist at the National Archives and Records Administration's Office of the Chief Records Officer of the Federal government, said these records are invaluable to a society.

"Closure of these records is based on a general understanding of a person's right to privacy," Wilson said, noting that he was speaking for himself, rather than in any official capacity for the National Archives. "Longstanding principles of common law state that this right expires at death.

"Records must be temporarily closed to satisfy this right to privacy. But in some Ohio counties, these records remain closed forever, creating a disconnect affecting both custodians and potential users."

Wilson characterized the continued practice of exempting disclosure as nothing more than misguided paternalism.

"Somebody might be embarrassed, even a century later, so best to just not let anybody see them," he jested. "We will protect you from yourself.

"Never mind that the people saved from potential 'embarrassment' are the very researchers who want to see them."

He offered his own circumstance in tracing his family's history back to England.

"A 42-year-old man named Sykes Hinson died in 1853 in London, England's infamous Colney Hatch Lunatic Asylum," Wilson continued. "He was my great-great-grandmother's brother.

"Am I ashamed of the fact that he spent at least the last quarter of his life in an insane asylum? No. Am I interested in his story - why he ended up there, how well he was treated, how and why he died there? Yes."

Thankfully for Wilson, the English records were available to him.

"But if the records were in Ohio, my ability to access them would be at the whim of a county judge," he said.

Perales said the century mark appears to be an adequate amount of time to pass before sensitive personal information is released.

"HB 138 is supported by County Archivists and Records Managers Association, and has been through preliminary vetting with state agencies and organizations including the office of the Ohio Attorney General, and so far has received no opposition," he added.

Several other states already have passed open access legislation for similar types of historical records.

Rep. Candice Keller, R-Middletown, jointly sponsored the bill with Perales, while another four House members have signed on as cosponsors.

A fourth hearing of the measure had not been scheduled as of publication.

Date Published: December 7, 2017


Copyright © 2017 The Daily Reporter - All Rights Reserved


Avoid packing on pounds during the holidays

During the holidays, do you find yourself overindulging in the pies, cakes, and cookies? Civilian Health Promotions Services can help keep you on track to avoid gaining those extra pounds while we celebrate the holiday season.

Gorillas make debut in Cincinnati Zoo’s new indoor habitat

The much-anticipated indoor habitat for Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden’s gorillas will open to the public, December 6. Donors and sponsors, including The Spaulding Foundation, Harry and Linda Fath, Farmer Family Foundation, and Gorilla Glue, officially cut the ribbon and previewed the facility earlier today.

Safe Food Handler Training - Youth Resource Center

The Montgomery County Youth Resource Center is offering Safe Food Handler Level 1 Training to youth ages 14 to 24. If you are interested in working in food service, this course is for you! Safe Food Handler empowers employees as they learn how food becomes unsafe and what their role is in keeping food safe. ServSafe® is the industry standard for food safety education. This class is for youth and young adults who want to have an advantage in the food service industry, which can be at a restaurant, grocery store, or food bank. Upon completion of this course, the participant will receive a certificate of completion.

Skinner pipe organ performances at The Dayton Art Institute

Hear the museum's recently restored Skinner pipe organ! Beginning November 30, the Dayton Chapter of the American Guild of Organists will present holiday organ performances in the Renaissance Auditorium every Thursday, from 1:00 to 3:00 p.m., through December 28.

UD falls 78-70 to Penn

The University of Dayton men's basketball fell to Penn 78-70 on Saturday at UD Arena. Stats were fairly even across the board except for three-point shooting.

Drug dealer who said lawyer 'tricked' him into plea deal has appeal denied

A three-judge panel recently affirmed a Scioto County Court of Common Pleas decision denying a man’s post-sentence motion to withdraw a guilty plea in his drug trafficking case.

Five Ohioans sentenced for insurance fraud after investigation

Five people across Ohio have been sentenced for insurance crimes resulting from investigative work by the Ohio Department of Insurance, department director Jillian Froment announced.

ODNR geologic research grants awarded for third year

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) has awarded geologic research grants to two Ohio graduate school students from the ODNR Division of Geological Survey’s Ohio Geology License Plate Fund. The student research will broaden understanding of the state’s natural history and may assist in future development of resources.

New projects expected to create more than $477 million in investments

Recently Governor John R. Kasich announced the approval of assistance for 15 projects set to create 2,338 new jobs and retain 1,857 jobs statewide. During its monthly meeting, the Ohio Tax Credit Authority (TCA) reviewed economic development proposals brought to the board by JobsOhio and its regional partners. Collectively, the projects are expected to result in more than $107 million in new payroll, and spur more than $477 million in investments across Ohio.

Fashion maven's group donates designer dresses to girls who can't afford them

School dresses aren't cheap, and many dresses today are far out of reach for low-income girls and their families.

Children’s charity and its telemarketer accused of bilking over $4.2 million from Ohio donors

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine recently announced a lawsuit against a purported children’s charity, its operators, and its fundraiser for allegedly defrauding Ohio donors and misleading them about how their money would be spent.

Disaster relief bill advances in Senate, raises constitutional question

A House bill devised to make it easier for out-of-state businesses and employees to come to the aid of Ohioans during a disaster landed a first hearing late last month before Senate committee members, who presumably will have to address a constitutional defect.

Legislation seeks incentives for more research on incurable diseases

A bill advanced by a southwest Ohio lawmaker that proposes a different tack for incentivizing medical research relating to incurable diseases secured a first hearing before House Health Committee members in recent weeks.

Man engaged in unauthorized practice of law

The Ohio Supreme Court recently decided that a Sidney man engaged in the unauthorized practice of law when he told a debt collector for the Ohio attorney general that he was the “authorized representative” of another person and demanded the collector pay his client $100,000.

Give outdoor enthusiasts the gift of the great outdoors

As the hustle and bustle of the holiday season continues in December, the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) has several opportunities to make gift giving a little easier this year. Why not give the gift of the great outdoors? Consider giving a gift that will encourage family members and friends to spend time outside and enjoy the beauty and fun that nature in Ohio has to offer!

Former Broadview Heights man sentenced to nearly six years in prison for defrauding Cuyahoga Heights School District out of $2.6 million

A former Broadview Heights man was sentenced to nearly six years in prison for his role in a scheme to defraud the Cuyahoga Heights School District out of millions of dollars, law enforcement officials said.

Supreme Court of Ohio issues suspensions to three attorneys

Three Ohio attorneys received partially stayed suspensions from the Ohio Supreme Court recently that suspend their law practice for six months.

31 victims of attorney theft reimbursed nearly $200,000

Nearly $200,000 was awarded to 31 victims of attorney theft, following a vote of the Board of Commissioners of the Lawyers’ Fund for Client Protection on Dec. 1. The compensation was in response to claims made against seven former or suspended attorneys who were found to have misappropriated client funds.

New digital resource launched for preschool learning

Ohio’s parents and educators have a new resource to help little learners ages 3-5 prepare for school and their futures with the INFOhio Early Learning Portal. The easy-to-navigate site contains more than 50 websites and apps chosen and evaluated by educators and librarians with expertise in early learning and literacy.

Two arrested and charged after ordering fentanyl from China

Two men were arrested and charged with attempted possession of fentanyl with intent to distribute, law enforcement officials said.