Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Third District: University of Findlay can continue suit for massive grass damage

 

Third District: University of Findlay can continue suit for massive grass damage

Dan Trevas, Supreme Court of Ohio

The University of Findlay can continue to seek about $325,000 from an insurance company for the costs to replace nearly 75 percent of the grass on campus that was killed when the wrong pesticide was used, and Ohio appeals court ruled.

USA Lawns, Inc. and its former president Brad Martin paid the university $250,000 in cash and labor after its insurer denied a claim to cover the April 2014 mishap. Martin argued his company entered into a settlement after the claim denial, and has objected to the university’s lawsuit against the company as a tactic to attempt to collect more money from the insurance company.

The Third District Court of Appeals recently affirmed a judgment by the Hancock County Common Pleas Court awarding the university $324,077. The court recognized that the university and USA Lawns entered into a “Covenant Not to Execute Judgment in Excess of Insurance Proceeds,” and that any money recouped by the school would have to come neither from USA Lawns nor Martin, but from Celina Mutual Insurance Company. Martin argued the agreement made the lawsuit pointless because Celina already has refused to cover USA Lawns.

Blades Destroyed by Bullseye

In its brief filed with the Third District, the university explained that USA Lawns was hired to do a two-step pesticide application on campus grass in the spring. The company first put down Dimension, a crab grass control pesticide, which was part of the plan. The second application was a pesticide called Battleship that killed weeds, but not grass. Instead, the company’s pesticide applicator mistakenly used Bullseye, which kills both weeds and grass. The university claimed that 300,000 square feet of grass was killed, reporting at the time that it represented about 75 percent of the grass on campus.

The university and Martin discussed a plan to address the school’s concern that it needed the grass replaced very soon because of upcoming graduation ceremonies, and late spring was the height of its student recruitment operations. The use of Dimension hampered the ability to use grass seed to replace the lawns and that new grass would come up “in little sprouts to form a little green haze” and that it would not be until the fall that grass would return to it full thickness.

Dimension would not impact the placement of more expensive sod, which Martin suggested in the denied claim by Celina Insurance.

Repair Agreement Wilts

In June 2014, the university and USA Lawns entered their covenant. Martin supervised the repairs of the grounds and part of the $250,000 the company was to provide to the school included $51,000 in labor. USA Lawns also paid $68,000 to another landscaping firm to do repairs, and paid $130,000 the school to cover part of its costs. The university stated it spent $324,077 of its own money to replace the grass.

As part of the agreement, USA Lawns agreed that the university would file a lawsuit against the company with the understanding that the intent was to seek damages from the company’s insurer. USA agreed to cooperate with the university. The agreement additionally stated that the school could attempt to sue the insurance company directly if it wished, and that any judgment the university would win against USA would be limited to the collection of insurance proceeds.

When the university filed its lawsuit as stated in the agreement, USA Lawns objected. The company asked for summary judgment in its favor, arguing that almost a year after the agreement, the university knew that Celina Insurance would not pay, and that even if it won a judgment against USA Lawns there is nothing to collect. The trial court denied the company’s request, allowing the university to pursue its nearly $325,000 in damages. USA Lawns appealed to the Third District.

Sodding Costs Sought

Writing for the Third District, Judge John R. Willamowski noted that in the covenant USA Lawns acknowledged that it is aware that under Ohio law, the only way the university can seek reimbursement from Celina Insurance is by suing the company. Only after a judgment is entered against a company can the university pursue the insurance company with legal action, he explained.

Judge Willamowski also rejected the company’s argument that covenant was an “accord and satisfaction” that established the university could seek no further damages from USA Lawns after it contributed $250,000 in cash and labor to the repair cost. He wrote the covenant included a provision to file a lawsuit to seek the insurance proceeds.

“Since the agreement included the lawsuit, the Appellants cannot claim that the suit violates the agreement,” the Third District opinion stated.

At the trial, Martin testified that the only way for the university to replace its grass to meet its needs was to use sod. Collectively the company and the school spent about $444,000 to do the repair. The Third District concluded that while the covenant may prevent the USA Lawns from having to pay any more, it cannot stop the university from seeking the money from the insurance company.

The Third District remanded the case to the common pleas court for further proceedings.

Judges William R. Zimmerman and Stephen R. Shaw concurred in the decision.

Univ. of Findlay v. Martin, 2017-Ohio-7016.

A PDF of the decision can be found at: https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/3/2017/2017-Ohio-7016.pdf

Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.

Date Published: August 24, 2017

 

Supreme Court of Ohio

 

Members of Ohio MS-13 arrested and charged

(Columbus) Thirteen individuals alleged to be members and associates of MS-13 were arrested in Central Ohio and Indiana recently.

21st Century Community Learning Center grants awarded

The Ohio Department of Education recently awarded approximately $44.3 million in new and continuing 21st Century Community Learning Center grants for Fiscal Year 2018.

Bill to thwart death penalty sentences for mentally ill has yet to progress

A bipartisan Senate effort that would scuttle death penalty sentences imposed against the mentally ill remains tied up in committee as lawmakers enjoyed the final weeks of a summer recess.

Task force seizes 200 pounds of marijuana, three arrested

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine, Montgomery County Sheriff Phil Plummer, U.S. Department of Homeland Security Investigations Special Agent in Charge Steve Francis, and members of the Miami Valley Bulk Smuggling Task Force announced recently the seizure of approximately 200 pounds of marijuana as part of an ongoing drug trafficking investigation.

'Freedom' is best response to white supremacy hatemongers

Let them march in Charlottesville. Let them speak.

The AFRL seeks innovative energy solutions

The Air Force Research Laboratory Advanced Power Technology Office is seeking innovative alternative energy and energy-efficient technology solutions with the recent release of its latest broad agency announcement, published July 19 on the Federal Business Opportunities website.

Montgomery County Tire Buyback event

On Sept. 24, 2017, Montgomery County Environmental Services will host its fifth Tire Buyback event. Residents can earn $2 for every scrap/used tire they bring, up to a maximum of 10 tires per vehicle.

The Cincinnati Zoo’s Baby Fiona update

The next milestone for Fiona will be transitioning from formula to solids so she is currently able to eat anything that Bibi is offered, but specifically given grain, beet pulp, apple, banana, and lettuce before and after each bottle feeding.

Dayton women's soccer falls short to Miami

The University of Dayton women's soccer team fought back and pulled within one goal at one point in the exhibition match, but fell 4-2 to visiting Miami Friday night at Baujan Field.

University of Dayton signs national pledge

President Eric F. Spina has joined CEO Action for Diversity & Inclusion, a growing coalition of more than 200 CEOs pledging to advance diversity and inclusion in the workplace.

University of Dayton’s class of 2021

The University of Dayton will welcome its largest and most diverse class in school history this fall.

Wright State, The Dayton Foodbank & Caresource helping others

On Aug. 11, over 500 families filed into the Wright State University Nutter Center parking lot. One by one the as The Dayton Foodbank provided the produce, Caresource the volunteers and Wright State’s Nutter Center the venue. This was the third consecutive year that Wright State welcomed the Dayton Foodbank’s distribution pick up in Greene County.

Ohio Chief Justice O’Connor named to lead two national court organizations

Ohio Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor has been elected president of the Conference of Chief Justices (CCJ) and chair of the National Center for State Courts (NCSC) Board of Directors. The one-year positions became effective recently during CCJ’s annual conference and NCSC’s Board of Directors meetings in Philadelphia.

New ways to comparison shop for health care

(BPT) As our nation seeks solutions to help improve the health care system, there is at least one goal we can all agree on: the importance of making health care quality and cost information more accessible to all Americans.

ABA House urges changes affecting undocumented immigrants, among other policy decisions

The American Bar Association House of Delegates, which determines association-wide policy, adopted policies over two days that urges Congress to add courthouses to the “sensitive locations” list for immigration enforcement and licensing groups to admit to the bar undocumented law school graduates under certain circumstances.

4 simple ways to stay productive and conquer your to-do list

(BPT) Did you know that in an average week, 75 percent of Americans skip doing something for themselves because they didn't adequately plan or allow enough time for it? Does looking at your to-do list feel so daunting that it discourages you from making any progress at all?

Canadian man charged with production of child pornography after meeting teen in Ohio

(Cleveland) A Canadian man arrested at a park in Rocky River was charged in federal court with production of child pornography.

Bill: Old records exempt from public disclosure law may see light of day

A bill before members of a committee in the Ohio House of Representatives may be an amateur genealogist's dream.

Small businesses, chamber oppose bill that would regulate employee hiring details

A bill crafted to protect some of the most private information of working individuals has come up against opposition in the Ohio House of Representatives.

Board of Professional Conduct concludes dual employment of specialized docket employees prohibited

The Board of Professional Conduct recently issued an advisory opinion concerning the dual employment of court employees in both a specialized drug court and a nonprofit drug treatment center under contract with the court.