Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Attorney suspended for misleading advertising of affiliation with Supreme Court justice

 

Attorney suspended for misleading advertising of affiliation with Supreme Court justice

Dan Trevas, Supreme Court of Ohio

The Ohio Supreme Court imposed a two-year, stayed suspension on an Ashtabula County attorney whose business card and law office sign implied he was still in partnership with a sitting Ohio Supreme Court justice.

The Board of Professional Conduct recommended Thomas C. Brown of Geneva receive a six-month stayed suspension for advertising his firm as the O’Neill & Brown Law Office. In a 4-3 per curiam decision, the Court wrote that six months would not “adequately protect the public from future harm,” and imposed the two-year sanction.

In a dissenting opinion, Justice Terrence O’Donnell wrote that Brown’s “deceitful conduct demands a serious sanction involving time out from the practice of law,” and that Brown should be indefinitely suspended.

Brown and Justice William M. O’Neill practiced together from 1981 to 1997 at the O’Neill & Brown Law Office.

Justice O’Neill did not participate in the case. Eighth District Court of Appeals Judge John Timothy McCormack was assigned to sit on the Court for the case.

Brown Renames Firm

Although Brown and O’Neill ceased practicing law together in 1997, Brown asked for Justice O’Neill’s consent in July 2015 to install a sign outside his office advertising the “O’Neill & Brown Law Office (EST 1981).” He also began distributing O’Neill & Brown Law Office business cards to court personnel, opposing attorneys, and potential clients.

That same month the Ashtabula County Bar Association began to investigate allegations of professional misconduct regarding the use of the law firm name, and Brown responded to the bar’s inquiry by explaining his past affiliation with Justice O’Neill. The bar association advised Justice O’Neill that Brown’s signs violated the rules governing Ohio attorneys, and Justice O’Neill instructed Brown to take down the sign.

The bar association filed a complaint with the professional conduct board claiming Brown violated three rules by using Justice O’Neill’s name, including making a false or misleading statement about the lawyer’s services, using a false or misleading firm name, and using the name of a lawyer who holds public office in a law firm’s name during a substantial period in which the officeholder is not regularly practicing with the firm.

A three-member panel of the board heard testimony in the matter, and a month after the hearing, the bar association alleged that Brown made false statements during the disciplinary process. The county bar found Brown was still using the O’Neill & Brown Law Office business card after testifying that he stopped using them, and that he told a disciplinary investigator that he took the offending sign down in September 2015, but witnesses had seen the sign remaining in view through November 2015.

The bar association provided documentation from the wife of a potential Brown client who received an O’Neill & Brown business card from Brown in April 2016. Brown admitted giving it to her and claimed it was unintentional. He said he carried a “rarely used” extra business card in his wallet and did not realize he gave the woman one of his discontinued cards. Brown also testified he was not certain of the date he took down the law firm sign and stated it was possible it remained up throughout November 2015.

Brown is the sole employee of the law firm. The board found the use of the sign and business cards and the claim the current firm was established in 1981 were violations of the rules against misleading statements. It also found Brown violated the law by including the name of an officeholder in a law firm name when the public official was not actively practicing with the firm. However, it found Brown’s handing out his business card and delay in taking down the signs did not violate the rules, and it recommended the sixth-month, stayed suspension.

Court Considers Sanction

When imposing a sanction, the Court considers several factors including aggravating circumstances that could enhance a penalty and mitigating factors that could lead to a less-severe punishment.

The Court noted that Brown had a prior disciplinary record. In 1999, the Court initiated an interim suspension of his license, which led to an indefinite suspension that continued until November 2006. Brown was suspended for violating a number of rules that included failing to file briefs in four client matters, threatening a judge who served as chairperson of the Ashtabula County grievance committee, making false statements in an effort to get a lawsuit against him dismissed, lying to a judge about his compliance with a court order, failing to attend scheduled court hearings, and failing to cooperate in a disciplinary investigation.

He also received three separate brief suspensions for not following attorney registration requirements in 2005, 2009, and 2015. Other aggravating factors the board found included:

Brown acted with a selfish motive

He committed multiple offenses

He did not acknowledge the wrongful nature of his conduct

He used Justice O’Neill’s name on the sign and business card four months after he was told it was a rule violation

The board found mitigating factors included:

Brown’s cooperative attitude during the disciplinary process

The conduct did not involve providing legal services

No clients were negatively impacted

Justice O’Neill participated in the decision to use the law firm name

The opinion stated that a six-month suspension would be inadequate in light of the aggravating factors that included using the prestige of Justice O’Neill’s position as a Supreme Court justice to enhance Brown’s reputation, his failure to comply with the notice that he was violating the rules, his past misconduct, and his failure to “acknowledge or appreciate” the nature of his misconduct.

The Court’s two-year stayed suspension requires that he remove any reference to the firm being established in 1981, permanently alter the sign within 60 days to remove the O’Neill name, destroy all O’Neill and Brown business cards within 14 days, commit no further misconduct, and refrain from advertising or communicating that he is practicing in the O’Neill & Brown Law Office except when making a biographical reference to his former affiliations. The Court concluded that if he violates any of those conditions the stay will be lifted and he will serve an entire two-year suspension.

Justices Sharon L. Kennedy, Judith L. French, and R. Patrick DeWine and Judge McCormack joined the majority opinion.

Dissent Finds Suspension Warranted

In his dissent, Justice O’Donnell concluded that receiving permission from Justice O’Neill to post the sign was not a mitigating, but rather an aggravating factor and he noted that Brown continued to use the O’Neill name on the sign after he was alerted by the bar association that it violated the rules and he continued using the firm’s business cards after he stipulated to the board that he had stopped.

Justice O’Donnell asserted that while the majority recognizes Brown’s selfish motive for using Justice O’Neill’s name and the prestige of Justice O’Neill’s position to enhance his reputation, it “fails to grasp that Brown also created an appearance of impropriety by representing he was practicing law in a legal partnership with a sitting justice....”

He concluded that an indefinite suspension was the appropriate sanction, and Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor and Justice Patrick F. Fischer concurred.

2016-1147. Ashtabula Cty. Bar Assn. v. Brown, Slip Opinion No. 2017-Ohio-5698.

Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.

Date Published: July 21, 2017

 

Supreme Court of Ohio

 

Task force seizes 400 pounds of marijuana, two arrested

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine, Montgomery County Sheriff Phil Plummer, U.S. Department of Homeland Security Investigations Special Agent in Charge Steve Francis, and members of the Miami Valley Bulk Smuggling Task Force announced recently the seizure of approximately 400 pounds of marijuana in connection with an investigation into a large-scale marijuana distribution organization operating between Dayton and Columbus.

Ohio and U.S. Employment Situation (Seasonally Adjusted), June 2017

Ohio's unemployment rate was 5.0 percent in June 2017, up from 4.9 percent in May 2017. Ohio’s nonagricultural wage and salary employment increased 11,500 over the month, from a revised 5,517,300 in May to 5,528,800 in June 2017.

Man sentenced to 200 months in prison for role in cocaine trafficking conspiracy

Oscar Collado-Rivera, 32, of New Albany, Ohio, was sentenced in U.S. District Court to 200 months in prison for conspiring with others to distribute more than 150 kilograms of cocaine.

University of Cincinnati to study prevalence of human trafficking in Ohio

In collaboration with Gov. John R. Kasich’s Ohio Human Trafficking Task Force, the Office of Criminal Justice Services (OCJS) has awarded funding to the University of Cincinnati (UC) to assess the extent to which youth and children are exploited in Ohio.

Fact: Multiple 529 Plans work best for multiple kids

Families with more than one child may wonder if they need more than one 529 plan to save for their children’s future college costs. While it’s not necessary, the benefits of a 529 plan customarily can be amplified best if each child has their own 529 account. Why? Here are a few reasons.

When a loved one dies…who pays the bills?

Q: Who is responsible for paying the bills of a deceased person?

Attorney who misappropriated $363,000 permanently disbarred

A Columbus personal-injury attorney was permanently disbarred by the Ohio Supreme Court recently for misappropriating more than $363,000 in settlements funds, mostly by not paying parties, other than her clients, who were entitled to portions of the settlement.

OHFA announces 2017 Housing Tax Credit Program Recipients, awarding more than $25 million to create affordable housing options

At its July 19, 2017, meeting, the Ohio Housing Finance Agency (OHFA) Board announced the recipients of the 2017 Housing Tax Credit (HTC) program awards, used to fund the construction, acquisition and rehabilitation of affordable housing communities throughout Ohio. Over $27 million in federal housing tax credits was awarded to 33 developments to create 1,698 housing units serving families, seniors and individuals with disabilities:

5 investment strategies that can outlast market spikes

(BPT) You're familiar with the saying "If it seems too good to be true, it probably is"?

Staying healthy while traveling overseas

(BPT) Each year, travelers from the United States (U.S.) head to popular destinations. And while many have Zika on their mind while traveling, and are aware of the need to bring sunscreen, bug repellant and other travel necessities, many don't know that cholera may be a bigger threat than they thought and most don't take the necessary measures to protect themselves from it.

Survey: More Americans see less media bias — but why?

Attention you so-called "enemies of the people" and alleged purveyors of biased reporting: There's reason to think fewer people than last year might see you that way, despite the ongoing, politicized attacks from multiple quarters on the news media's credibility.

No rights warnings required to question intoxicated driver in police vehicle front seat

Placing a suspect in the front seat of a police cruiser during a traffic stop does not alone determine if the officer needs to read the suspect his rights before questioning, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled recently.

The PUCO answers your questions about budget billing

The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) would like to remind consumers that in addition to energy conservation and energy choice, budget billing is another way to manage your utility bills.

Seven men from Cuyahoga County indicted for firearms offenses

Seven men from Cuyahoga County were indicted on federal firearms charges, said Acting U.S. Attorney David Sierleja and Trevor Velinor, ATF Special Agent in Charge for the Columbus Field Division.

Proposal would allow medical first responders to carry firearms

A Cincinnati emergency room physician has joined first responders from around the Buckeye State to back a proposed bill that would provide for firearms training for tactical medical professionals, who would be allowed to carry a firearm in a concealed manner while on duty.

Applications now available for $3 million in Ohio law enforcement grants to address opioid epidemic

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine announced recently the application process is now open for Ohio law enforcement teams to apply for $3 million in new state grant money that will replicate or expand Drug Abuse Response Teams (DARTs) and Quick Response Teams (QRTs) to address the opioid epidemic in Ohio.

Simplify Your 529 Withdrawal Process

NOTE: This is the process for CollegeAdvantage Direct 529 Plan accounts only. The process is different for Guaranteed Plan accounts. Here is guidance for withdrawals from the Guaranteed Plan.

Proposal designed to shore up Ohio's school workers' health care fund

The annual 3 percent cost of living adjustment guaranteed to Ohio's retired public school workers through the School Employees Retirement System, or SERS, is at stake if current law and funding remain unchanged, according to a northwest Ohio lawmaker.

4 strategies to grow your finances in retirement

(BPT) Retirement is the time in your life when you can throw off the shackles of your daily responsibilities and truly enjoy the fruits of everything you spent years working toward. It's an empowering feeling and you've earned it. You've planned and you've saved, but now that you're here, don't make the mistake of believing your financial planning is over.

SCC baseball player named OCCAC Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year

Sinclair Community College and the Ohio Community College Athletic Conference (OCCAC) announced June 21 that freshman baseball player Blaze Glenn is this year’s 2016-17 OCCAC Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year.