Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Woman in California-to-Ohio meth ring loses appeal for shorter sentence


Woman in California-to-Ohio meth ring loses appeal for shorter sentence

ANNIE YAMSON, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

A federal court of appeals ruled recently that a woman's role in a meth distribution ring was not so minimal as to warrant a reduction in her sentence.

The defendant, Karla Ruiz, appealed from the judgment of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, which denied her a mitigating role reduction under the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines.

Ruiz pleaded guilty in the federal district court to conspiracy to distribute and to possess with intent to distribute methamphetamine.

Court documents state that Ruiz played a small role in a meth ring that distributed the drug in California and transported it to Ohio.

At trial, both the defense and the prosecution agreed that Ruiz had a mitigating role in the offense but a probation officer disagreed and recommended against the application of an offense-level reduction.

At sentencing, the district court overruled the objections of the parties and concluded that the evidence did not support "the notion that Ruiz was substantially less culpable than the average participant in the criminal activity."

Ruiz was ultimately sentenced to almost four years in federal prison followed by three years of supervised release.

In her appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit, Ruiz challenged the district court's denial of a reduction of her offense level.

According to her, the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines "provide a range of adjustments for a defendant who plays a part in committing the offense that makers her substantially less culpable than the average participant."

"The decision to grant a mitigating role reduction 'is based on the totality of the circumstances and involves a determination that is heavily dependent upon the facts of the particular case," the court of appeals wrote in its per curiam opinion. "We therefore review the denial of a mitigating role reduction for clear error."

According to Ruiz, her role in the meth conspiracy included receiving and holding the drug until someone else retrieved it.

Ruiz argued that she only did what her boyfriend, who was incarcerated, wanted her to do in the hopes of maintaining their internet relationship.

She contended that she did not originate any schemes to distribute the meth nor did she exercise any control over the plan or stand to benefit financially.

"In finding that Ruiz was not substantially less culpable than the average participant, the district court was 'especially influenced' by the fact that she had direct telephone contact with two incarcerated leaders of the methamphetamine conspiracy and noted that 'their ability to carry out this transaction presumptively would have been very limited without her support,'" the appellate panel wrote.

Citing a 2001 6th Circuit court ruling, the appellate court held that "a defendant who plays a lesser role in a criminal scheme may nonetheless fail to qualify as a minor participant if his role was indispensable or critical to the success of the scheme, or if his importance in the overall scheme was such as to justify his sentence."

In addition to having direct contact with the imprisoned ring leaders of the drug conspiracy, the circuit court held that Ruiz accepted the meth, packaged it for shipping from California to Ohio, turned it over to another participant for mailing, obtained a photograph of the shipping label and forwarded it to her incarcerated boyfriend and, at his direction, tracked the package.

"Based on the totality of the circumstances, the district court did not clearly err in denying Ruiz a mitigating role reduction," the circuit court held.

Ruiz also attacked the governments tactics in prosecuting her case, arguing that it assured her that it would argue on her behalf and then took a different stance upon her appeal. She claimed that the switch "will have a chilling effect on plea negotiations."

The appellate court disagreed, noting that the government only argued that the district court acted as a factfinder between two permissible views of the evidence.

"The fact that the government agreed to a sentencing adjustment before the district court does not mean that the government is estopped from arguing on appeal that the district court did not err in declining to award the adjustment," the appellate panel concluded, citing court precedent. "For these reasons, we affirm Ruiz's sentence."

Chief Judge R. Guy Cole and Judges Jane Stranch and Bernice Donald formed the appellate panel.

The case is cited United States v. Ruiz, Case No. 16-3205.

Date Published: February 24, 2017


Copyright © 2017 The Daily Reporter - All Rights Reserved


Supreme Court of Ohio heard four oral arguments yesterday, including one on student searches

The Ohio Supreme Court yesterday heard oral arguments in four cases yesterday and heard an additional four the day before that.

Man indicted for heroin and firearms violations

A Youngstown man was indicted for selling heroin and illegally having firearms, said Carole S. Rendon, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Ohio, and FBI Special Agent in Charge Stephen D. Anthony.

Ohio Collaborative Community-Police Advisory Board establishes bias free policing standard

Recently, the Ohio Collaborative Community-Police Advisory Board (Ohio Collaborative) established a new statewide standard on Bias Free Policing during its meeting at the Ohio Department of Public Safety. This is the seventh standard adopted by the Ohio Collaborative, and states:

3 things you should know about 'surprise medical bills'

(BPT) Patients receiving medical care increasingly also receive something unexpected and troubling - a bill they thought would be paid by their health insurance plan.

Drug conspiracy leader loses bid for lower sentence in federal court

The ringleader of a Florida-to-Ohio Oxycodone distribution operation recently lost his plea for a lower sentence in a federal court of appeals.

Attorney convicted of bribery conspiracy indefinitely suspended

The Ohio Supreme Court recently indefinitely suspended a Strongsville attorney convicted of felonies for his role in a bribery scheme involving prominent Cleveland attorney Anthony Calabrese III, who was disbarred and is serving a nine-year federal prison sentence for bribery.

New Supreme Court of Ohio website connects courts seeking to collaborate

The Ohio Supreme Court recently unveiled a new website aimed at facilitating resource sharing for Ohio courts.

Ohio EPA announces new statewide mosquito control grant recipients

Ohio EPA Director Craig W. Butler and Ohio Department of Health Director Richard Hodges recently announced funding for community health departments and related public entities across the state. Mosquito Control Grants help mitigate the spread of mosquito-borne viruses such as Zika, West Nile and La Cross Encephalitis.

Ohio couple charged with conspiracy to obstruct justice, tax violations

A nine-count indictment was filed charging a Brunswick couple with failing to make payments to support the pension and benefits fund of its employees and then obstructing the subsequent investigation, said Carole S. Rendon, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Ohio.

Ohio State Highway Patrol announces 2016 Leadership Awards

The Ohio State Highway Patrol announced the winners of their 2016 Leadership Awards recently. The ceremony recognizes dozens of state and district award winners for contributions to the division and the state of Ohio.

Statewide commercial, industrial recycling data survey gathers useful data

It’s once again time for Ohio to request data from commercial and industrial businesses regarding their recycling activities. The data will be used to identify recycling trends and opportunities and indicate whether Ohio is meeting its recycling goals.

Make a natural investment to protect northwest Ohio's State Nature Preserves

More than 20 state nature preserves in northwestern Ohio offer Ohioans an opportunity to escape into nature, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR). Many of these special places exist in large part to the generosity of Ohioans who donated a portion of their tax refunds to the State Nature Preserves Fund.

Supreme Court of Ohio heard four oral arguments yesterday, including one on double jeopardy

The Ohio Supreme Court yesterday heard oral arguments in four cases yesterday and will hear another four today. Among the four cases heard yesterday, on raised questions about what does and does not constitute double jeopardy.

OSU researchers develop pathology scanner

Kasich announces appointments of Daniel Conway and Lawrence Friedeman to the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio

Recently Governor John R. Kasich announced the following appointments:

College Advantage partners with America Saves

CollegeAdvantage is pleased to participate in America Save Week, which will run Monday, Feb. 27 - Saturday, March 4. America Saves is an organization, managed by the Consumer Federation of America (CFA), which is dedicated to helping individuals save money, reduce household debt, and build wealth. In 2007, America Saves Week was established to encourage households and individuals to develop good saving habits.

Supreme Court of Ohio: Powell wins zoning ordinance ballot dispute

The Ohio Supreme Court recently rejected an effort to compel the Powell City Council to place a referendum regarding a zoning ordinance on the May 2017 ballot.

Proposed bill would update protections for state workers

The Cincinnati Republican lawmaker who championed changes to the state's civil rights laws pertaining to employment during the previous session of the Ohio Legislature has resurrected effort in House Bill 2.

State of Ohio releases framework to reduce nutrients in Lake Erie Basin

The State of Ohio has released the framework that is being used to reduce phosphorus entering Lake Erie under the Western Basin of Lake Erie Collaborative Agreement, which was signed in June 2015 by Ohio Lt. Governor Mary Taylor, Michigan and Ontario with a goal of reducing phosphorus loading to Lake Erie by 20 percent by 2020 and 40 percent by 2025.

Ohio Medicaid Providers Owe More than $1 Million

(Columbus) Examinations of four northeast Ohio Medicaid providers identified more than $1 million in overpayments recently, according to reports released by Auditor of State Dave Yost.