Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - News Supreme Court of Ohio: Legislative fix necessary for cocaine prosecutions as a result of court ruling


Supreme Court of Ohio: Legislative fix necessary for cocaine prosecutions as a result of court ruling

KEITH ARNOLD, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

A legislative fix relative to a holding by the Supreme Court of Ohio last year in State v. Gonzales, Slip Opinion 2016-Ohio-8319, is the motive behind a new measure introduced to the state House of Representatives.

And, perhaps, no legislator is better equipped to devise a legislative patch than former Supreme Court Justice Bob Cupp, a Republican representative from Lima.

House Bill 4 would restore statutory penalties for cocaine possession offenses relating to trafficking of the drug.

During testimony in support of the measure last week, Cupp told members of the House Criminal Justice Committee that the high court ruling in Gonzales changed how a prosecutor must go about arguing such an offense during the penalty phase.

The holding now requires a prosecutor to prove the quantity of pure cocaine rather than the long-standing precedent of proving the quantity of any mixture or compound containing cocaine, testimony detailed.

"The trafficking in cocaine penalty section appears to suffer from the same wording defect identified by the court," Cupp told his peers.

He noted Ohio law previously never was interpreted to require the disaggregation of a cocaine from any filler present in a mixture in order to meet the quantity requirement for the various penalty tiers and Bureau of Criminal Investigation and Identification laboratories are not accredited to perform this such analysis for use as evidence in court proceedings.

Cupp and fellow lawmaker and HB 4 joint sponsor, Rep. John Rogers, D-Mentor-on-the-Lake, reasoned that the new standard would result in only fifth-degree felony prosecutions.

"Under this situation, many if not most offenders will be subject only to a community control sanction if they have not previously been convicted of a felony offense," Cupp continued. "Courts only have the discretion to impose a prison sentence for these fifth-degree felonies in limited situations, usually when violence was involved in the offense.

"As the law now stands, drug dealers and traffickers are incentivized to possess and traffic in larger quantities of cocaine because the penalty would be of no greater consequence if the dealers and traffickers are apprehended with large quantities rather than smaller quantities."

According to analysis of the bill, provided by the Ohio Legislative Service Commission, HB 4 modifies the wording of the Drug Trafficking and Drug Possession Laws in connection with the penalties for trafficking and possession of cocaine.

Specifically, the bill removes the words "of cocaine" in connection with the amount involved throughout the drug trafficking and possession statutes.

Rogers characterized the consequence of the Supreme Court's ruling in Gonzales as a dangerous and new trajectory.

"Instead of effectively handcuffing law enforcement from keeping dangerous drug dealers off our streets, I believe that we should be handcuffing the criminals who make our state and communities less safe with dangerous drugs," he said upon the bill's introduction.

Cupp said penalty tiers will once again clearly apply to "cocaine or a compound, mixture, preparation or substance containing cocaine" of the weight specified after HB 4 is enacted.

The lawmakers attached an emergency clause to the measure to mitigate any unintended, dangerous consequences of the court ruling.

The clause makes the law effective immediately upon the governor's signature.

"Every day we delay in repairing the statute, the lowest penalty will continue to apply for cocaine possession, and likely for trafficking in cocaine," Cupp concluded.

More than a dozen lawmakers joined the joint sponsors in support of the measure, which was scheduled for further testimony this week.

Date Published: February 23, 2017


Copyright © 2017 The Daily Reporter - All Rights Reserved


Supreme Court of Ohio heard four oral arguments yesterday, including one on student searches

The Ohio Supreme Court yesterday heard oral arguments in four cases yesterday and heard an additional four the day before that.

Man indicted for heroin and firearms violations

A Youngstown man was indicted for selling heroin and illegally having firearms, said Carole S. Rendon, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Ohio, and FBI Special Agent in Charge Stephen D. Anthony.

Ohio Collaborative Community-Police Advisory Board establishes bias free policing standard

Recently, the Ohio Collaborative Community-Police Advisory Board (Ohio Collaborative) established a new statewide standard on Bias Free Policing during its meeting at the Ohio Department of Public Safety. This is the seventh standard adopted by the Ohio Collaborative, and states:

3 things you should know about 'surprise medical bills'

(BPT) Patients receiving medical care increasingly also receive something unexpected and troubling - a bill they thought would be paid by their health insurance plan.

Drug conspiracy leader loses bid for lower sentence in federal court

The ringleader of a Florida-to-Ohio Oxycodone distribution operation recently lost his plea for a lower sentence in a federal court of appeals.

Attorney convicted of bribery conspiracy indefinitely suspended

The Ohio Supreme Court recently indefinitely suspended a Strongsville attorney convicted of felonies for his role in a bribery scheme involving prominent Cleveland attorney Anthony Calabrese III, who was disbarred and is serving a nine-year federal prison sentence for bribery.

New Supreme Court of Ohio website connects courts seeking to collaborate

The Ohio Supreme Court recently unveiled a new website aimed at facilitating resource sharing for Ohio courts.

Ohio EPA announces new statewide mosquito control grant recipients

Ohio EPA Director Craig W. Butler and Ohio Department of Health Director Richard Hodges recently announced funding for community health departments and related public entities across the state. Mosquito Control Grants help mitigate the spread of mosquito-borne viruses such as Zika, West Nile and La Cross Encephalitis.

Ohio couple charged with conspiracy to obstruct justice, tax violations

A nine-count indictment was filed charging a Brunswick couple with failing to make payments to support the pension and benefits fund of its employees and then obstructing the subsequent investigation, said Carole S. Rendon, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Ohio.

Ohio State Highway Patrol announces 2016 Leadership Awards

The Ohio State Highway Patrol announced the winners of their 2016 Leadership Awards recently. The ceremony recognizes dozens of state and district award winners for contributions to the division and the state of Ohio.

Statewide commercial, industrial recycling data survey gathers useful data

It’s once again time for Ohio to request data from commercial and industrial businesses regarding their recycling activities. The data will be used to identify recycling trends and opportunities and indicate whether Ohio is meeting its recycling goals.

Make a natural investment to protect northwest Ohio's State Nature Preserves

More than 20 state nature preserves in northwestern Ohio offer Ohioans an opportunity to escape into nature, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR). Many of these special places exist in large part to the generosity of Ohioans who donated a portion of their tax refunds to the State Nature Preserves Fund.

Supreme Court of Ohio heard four oral arguments yesterday, including one on double jeopardy

The Ohio Supreme Court yesterday heard oral arguments in four cases yesterday and will hear another four today. Among the four cases heard yesterday, on raised questions about what does and does not constitute double jeopardy.

OSU researchers develop pathology scanner

Kasich announces appointments of Daniel Conway and Lawrence Friedeman to the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio

Recently Governor John R. Kasich announced the following appointments:

College Advantage partners with America Saves

CollegeAdvantage is pleased to participate in America Save Week, which will run Monday, Feb. 27 - Saturday, March 4. America Saves is an organization, managed by the Consumer Federation of America (CFA), which is dedicated to helping individuals save money, reduce household debt, and build wealth. In 2007, America Saves Week was established to encourage households and individuals to develop good saving habits.

Supreme Court of Ohio: Powell wins zoning ordinance ballot dispute

The Ohio Supreme Court recently rejected an effort to compel the Powell City Council to place a referendum regarding a zoning ordinance on the May 2017 ballot.

Proposed bill would update protections for state workers

The Cincinnati Republican lawmaker who championed changes to the state's civil rights laws pertaining to employment during the previous session of the Ohio Legislature has resurrected effort in House Bill 2.

State of Ohio releases framework to reduce nutrients in Lake Erie Basin

The State of Ohio has released the framework that is being used to reduce phosphorus entering Lake Erie under the Western Basin of Lake Erie Collaborative Agreement, which was signed in June 2015 by Ohio Lt. Governor Mary Taylor, Michigan and Ontario with a goal of reducing phosphorus loading to Lake Erie by 20 percent by 2020 and 40 percent by 2025.

Ohio Medicaid Providers Owe More than $1 Million

(Columbus) Examinations of four northeast Ohio Medicaid providers identified more than $1 million in overpayments recently, according to reports released by Auditor of State Dave Yost.