Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - Woman who scammed $360,000 from unemployment agencies loses appeal


Woman who scammed $360,000 from unemployment agencies loses appeal

ANNIE YAMSON, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

The federal 6th Circuit Court of Appeals recently rejected arguments from a woman who challenged the prison sentence she received after she pleaded guilty to numerous charges of mail and wire fraud, identity theft and money laundering.

Darnell Nash was sentenced by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio to 175 months in prison for a conspiracy that took place between March 2012 and January 2013.

According to court documents, Nash and several accomplices filed fraudulent claims for unemployment insurance in at least six states.

In those states, Nash registered as a fake employer then, she and her coconspirators distributed flyers purporting to offer financial assistance in low-income neighborhoods.

When people called the hotline listed on the flyer, they were asked for their names, dates of birth and Social Security numbers. That information was then used to apply for unemployment benefits.

In all, Nash took in about $360,000 from the state unemployment agencies. Her prison sentence included an enhancement for defrauding vulnerable victims and another enhancement for the sheer number of victims — more than 50.

On appeal, Nash argued that the enhancements were not backed by sufficient evidence.

Judge Raymond Kethledge, writing on behalf of the 6th Circuit court’s three-judge appellate panel, noted that, under the federal sentencing guidelines, vulnerable victims are those who are particularly susceptible to the crime being committed.

He pointed out that Nash specifically targeted low-income neighborhoods with flyers that read, “Many American families are struggling under an increasing number of bills, debts and financial obligations. When you and your family are experiencing this stress, call us. We can help!”

“Nash thus crafted a fraudulent message to which she thought her audience would be particularly susceptible,” Kethledge wrote. “That her scheme netted $360,000 suggests that her audience was as susceptible as Nash thought it would be.”

With regard to the multivictim enhancement, Nash admitted that she fraudulently used more than 50 people’s identities but she argued that they were not necessarily victims because they willingly provided their information.

“But those people did not consent to the use of their information in a mail and wire fraud scheme,” Kethledge wrote. “Suffice it to say that victims of identity theft are victims for purposes of this enhancement.”

Nash’s final argument on appeal was that she should have been granted a downward departure in her calculated sentence because of mitigating circumstances, specifically, her gender dysphoria and her desire to transition from a man to a woman.

“But the district court allowed both Nash and her lawyer to argue at length about Nash’s gender dysphoria at sentencing,” Kethledge wrote. “And the court then explicitly considered and rejected a downward departure.

“The record thus makes clear that the court was aware of its discretion to make a downward departure and chose not to make one.”

With nothing else to review, the court of appeal affirmed the judgment of the district court.

Judge Edmund Sargus sat by designation from the Southern District of Ohio and concurred along with Judge Deborah Cook.

The case is cited United States v. Darnell Nash, case No. 15-3003.

Date Published: June 6, 2016


Copyright © 2016 The Daily Reporter - All Rights Reserved


Supreme Court heard four cases this week, including death-row inmate objection to appeals process for DNA testing requests

Earlier this week the Supreme Court of Ohio heard oral arguments in four cases; three cases on Tuesday, May 31 and one cases on Wednesday, June 1 at the Thomas J. Moyer Ohio Judicial Center in Columbus.

OSU study finds big pay gap between men, women in science fields

According to a new Ohio State University study using previously unavailable data, women with Ph.D.s in science and engineering fields earn 31 percent less than man.

Retired lawyers may be a solution to getting legal help for low-income Ohioans

This year, the Supreme Court of Ohio’s new emeritus pro bono attorney registration status will mark yet another turning point in Ohio’s quest to increase access to justice in the state.

Senate ag leaders want science emphasized in regulations

The Senate Agriculture Committee got its first look at a resolution that takes aim at regulatory actions with less-than-scientific basis.

Ohioans facing issues with cemeteries can file complaint

Memorial Day was just here and many Ohioans spent the day visiting cemeteries to pay their respects to loved ones and our nation’s veterans. Visits to cemeteries sometimes lead to unwanted family frustrations when the cemetery is not well kept, and often people do not know where to turn for help. That is where the Ohio Department of Commerce gets involved.

Col. Alden Hilton takes command of USAFSAM

WRIGHT-PATTERSON AIR FORCE BASE, Ohio -- Col. Alden Hilton took the reins of the United States Air Force School of Aerospace Medicine from Col. Christian Benjamin, who is retiring after 30 years of service, during a change of command ceremony May 20 at USAFSAM.

Research reveals the Genetic link between fussiness as an infant and the risk for behavior problems later

A new study by Jackson Goodnight, a University of Dayton associate professor in psychology, reveals the link between fussiness as an infant and the risk for behavior problems later in life may be driven by genetics instead of environmental factors.

Wright State students create the Dayton Mobile Market

Students hope to deliver fresh produce to Dayton residents by summer

Golpher, Wenzler Concludes Play at Vanderbilt Regional

Wright State junior golfer Ryan Wenzler concluded play at the NCAA Regionals Wednesday the 18th of May, held at the Vanderbilt Legends Club in Franklin, Tennessee.

WS Baseball Defeats UIC in Regular-Season Finale

The Wright State baseball team closed out the regular season on a high note last Saturday, connecting for three home runs, including a pair of three-run blasts by Ryan Fucci, in defeating UIC 12-5 at Curtis Granderson Stadium.

Attorney General DeWine sues man accused of illegally placing over 1 million robocalls to consumers

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine recently announced a lawsuit against a man accused of placing illegal robocalls to consumers in Ohio and other states.

Phone stalking bill ready for Kasich to sign

A bill that expands a menacing offense by stalking and harassment by phone or other telecommunications device was sent to Gov. John Kasich for his signature earlier in mid May.

Woman accused of endangering her teenage son wins appeal

In the case of a mother who was found guilty of endangering her teenage son, the 1st District Court of Appeals recently ruled there was not enough evidence to sustain the conviction.

Ohio lakes will be more crowded this summer as number of boaters grows

Boaters are gearing up for a warm summer, and the number of boaters in Ohio is on the rise.

Supreme Court of Ohio rejects murder conviction appeal

The Ohio Supreme Court recently affirmed the aggravated murder conviction of a Youngstown man whose previous death sentence had been vacated.

Court rules man used his bogus company to launder money

A federal court recently called a criminal defendant’s company a “mere facade” and ordered that it relinquish all interest life insurance policies taken out on the defendant’s father.

Ohio lawmakers adopt caution Washington against 'federal tax grab'

The Ohio Senate recently adopted a House concurrent resolution that puts Congress and President Barack Obama on notice about the need to preserve the tax-exempt status of municipal bonds.

PUCO provides definitions to common utility bill terms

The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) wants to help Ohio consumers better understand common terms that appear on utility bills.

Program offers insight into law for middle school students

(Columbus) Ohio middle school students descended on Columbus State Community College on Friday, May 13th, to participate in the 2016 Middle School We the People State Showcase.

Attorney General DeWine announces settlement with professional solicitor over charitable filings

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine recently announced a settlement with a Virginia-based professional solicitor that conducted phone and mail solicitations in Ohio on behalf of charities.