Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Daily Court Reporter - Federal court upholds immunity for Wood County officer in excessive force claim

 

Federal court upholds immunity for Wood County officer in excessive force claim

ANNIE YAMSON, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

The United States 6th Circuit Court of Appeals recently affirmed a judgment granting qualified immunity to a Wood County police officer in an excessive force case.

The decision upheld the ruling of Judge Jeffrey James Helmick of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio at Toledo granting summary judgment to Deputy Jody Swoap of the Wood County Sheriff’s Office.

In an opinion authored by Judge Robert Cleland, who sat by designation on the 6th Circuit’s three-judge appellate panel, the reviewing court reminded readers to follow the reasonable orders of police.

“This Fourth Amendment excessive force claim arises from the familiar setting of an interaction between an officer and an angry, uncooperative citizen,” Cleland wrote. “The facts illustrate yet again why it is a bad idea to question and argue and to physically resist an investigating officer’s reasonable commands and directions.”

The plaintiff in the case was the estate of Robert Getz, administered by his wife, because Getz died due to unrelated reasons before the case made it to an appeal.

According to case summary, Swoap was sitting in his cruiser at about 7:20 p.m. on Nov. 27, 2011, near Bowling Green when he saw an oncoming car with only one operational headlight.

Swoap followed the vehicle, intending to conduct a stop, but the offending car did not immediately pull over after Swoap activated his overhead lights.

Instead, the driver, Getz, continued down the road until he pulled into a residential driveway, passed the home on the property and continued on until he made it to a barn.

Court documents state that Getz circled in front of the barn and then drove his car in Swoap’s direction, stopping when he was “bumper to bumper” with the cruiser. Getz then backed up and angled his car as though to drive around the cruiser but Swoap maneuvered in a way that prevented Getz from leaving the scene.

When Getz was eventually persuaded to exit his vehicle, he was agitated and repeatedly yelled for Swoap to get off his property. He tried to leave the scene several times despite the fact that Swoap repeatedly informed him that he was not free to leave.

Eventually, Swoap managed to place a physically resistant Getz into handcuffs and backup arrived in the form of Sgt. Timothy Spees.

Trisha Getz, Getz’s daughter, was also at the scene. She testified that her father complained multiple times that the handcuffs were hurting him and that Swoap offered to summon medical attention for him.

According to Spees and Swoap, shortly after Spees arrived, he asked Swoap if he was aware that Getz was bleeding from the handcuffs. Swoap said he was not aware and the handcuffs were removed.

According to a police log of radio dispatches, the entire ordeal took place in about five minutes. However, Trisha testified that she was outside and her father was handcuffed for approximately 20 minutes before Spees arrived and the cuffs were removed.

On July 10, 2013, Getz filed a complaint against Swoap and the sheriff of Wood County alleging false arrest, excessive force and failure to train and supervise. The district court granted summary judgment to the police on all of the claims but the excessive force claim was the only one to make it to an appeal.

Considering the evidence, the 6th Circuit court upheld that district court’s ruling that Swoap was entitled to qualified immunity because his actions were reasonable.

“It is undisputed that Getz was behaving belligerently before and after the handcuffs were applied, that Getz resisted Swoap’s attempts to place him under arrest, that Getz said that he intended to flee the scene and that Getz did, in fact, try to flee the scene,” Cleland wrote.

Swoap admitted that he did not check the handcuffs or double lock them to prevent them from tightening, but the court of appeals held that, in the face of a struggling arrestee, Swoap’s conduct was understandable and “not all conduct that causes an arrestee discomfort or pain violates the Fourth Amendment.”

“We hold that, given the arrestee’s resistance and general noncompliance, Swoap did not violate the Fourth Amendment when he applied handcuffs without checking for tightness and double locking the moment of the arrest,” Cleland wrote. “Qualified immunity applies to this claim.”

The appellate panel also held that Trisha’s testimony that her father was in handcuffs and in pain for 20 minutes was clearly disputed by record.

“Taking Trisha’s other testimony and the undisputed police log together, no reasonable jury could credit Trisha’s opinion that she was outside for 20 minutes,” Cleland wrote. “The police radio log is clear — and no party disagrees — that about four and a half minutes passed between Getz’s arrest and Spees’ arrival.”

Considering all of the evidence and Getz’s noncompliance, the court of appeals concluded that none of Swoap’s conduct violated the Fourth Amendment and that he was entitled to qualified immunity.

Judges Raymond Kethledge and Richard Griffin joined Cleland to form the majority.

The case is cited Getz v. Swoap, case No. 15-3514.

Date Published: September 5, 2016

 

Copyright © 2016 The Daily Reporter - All Rights Reserved

 

Federal court upholds immunity for Wood County officer in excessive force claim

The United States 6th Circuit Court of Appeals recently affirmed a judgment granting qualified immunity to a Wood County police officer in an excessive force case.

Lack of dental care a growing problem for some Ohioans

Many Ohioans cannot get affordable dental care in their communities, according to a statewide nonprofit health organization.

Township trustees illegally replaced member on military leave

Spencer Township trustees in Lucas County improperly declared that a trustee on military leave vacated his office and the trustees then illegally replaced him with an outgoing trustee who lost his re-election bid, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled recently.

Pair sentenced to prison for theft from legendary golfer

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Timothy McGinty announced recently that two Brecksville residents have been sentenced to serve time in prison after being convicted of stealing money from legendary late professional golfer Charles Sifford Sr.

Drug dealers sentenced to prison for selling fatal mix of heroin and fentanyl

Two Marion men were sentenced to prison for selling a mixture of heroin and fentanyl that resulted in an overdose death last year, law enforcement officials said.

Lieutenant Governor Mary Taylor reminds parents of young athletes to review insurance for sports injury coverage

Another school year has arrived and Ohio’s youth are also returning to athletic competition. News headlines remind parents of concussion risks and appropriate protective gear. But parents, are you financially protected if your child is injured requiring medical treatment?

WSU Raiders announce nonleague basketball schedule

The 2016-17 Wright State men’s basketball home schedule will include a few familiar faces and a few new faces as the Raiders will host a Thanksgiving weekend invitational that includes three post-season teams as well as other home match ups with local foes Miami (OH) and Toledo. The strong road slate includes Southern Illinois, Kent State, Loyola (IL), Murray State, Georgia State and Penn State of the Big Ten.

Dayton Professor named visiting scholar for the SEC

University of Dayton finance professor Fukuo Albert Wang has been named a visiting scholar for the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in Washington, D.C.

New brain imaging program offered as Sinclair’s fall semester begins

Sinclair College began its regular fall term on Monday, August 22, 2016 with numerous new programs available to students that will lead to filling in-demand jobs in the Dayton Region. Overall fall enrollment is projected to match last fall, with many more students enrolling in the 2nd and 3rd special fall terms starting in mid-September and mid-October respectively. Overall, Sinclair is on track to enroll at least 28,000 unduplicated individuals in college credit programs between summer, this current fall, and the end of the school year next spring.

University of Dayton offers course for tech savvy lawyers

Newly minted lawyers are facing 21st Century practices that include virtual law firms and court rooms as well as automated case management, document assembly and document review, so the University of Dayton School of Law is responding with what is believed to be the nation's first technology competencies credential.

Flyers football completes big weekend with scrimmage, media day

With 10 days of preseason camp in the books, the University of Dayton football team used last weekend to change gears, holding the Flyers' big preseason scrimmage on Saturday night and the team's annual Media Day on Sunday.

Five indicted for selling heroin or fentanyl that caused overdoses

Five Lorain County men were indicted in federal court for selling heroin and/or fentanyl that resulted in overdoses.

Bill would make electronic records official records

A pair of Ohio lawmakers recently took up one of the causes of the Uniform Law Commission by introducing legislation that would authenticate electronic legal material, preserve it and make it permanently available to the public.

Man convicted of murder as a juvenile loses appeal

In a per curiam opinion issued by the 11th District Court of Appeals, a three-judge panel held that a man convicted of murder as a juvenile in 1987 was properly bound over to a common pleas court and that he was not entitled to a writ of habeas corpus.

ODRC becomes first to receive national Lucy Webb Hayes Award for commitment to prison safety standards

The Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction (ODRC) has become the first prison system in the United States to receive the American Correctional Association’s (ACA) Lucy Webb Hayes Award. This award is presented to an agency that demonstrates a strong commitment to public safety by ensuring all areas of operations meet highly regarded and nationally recognized industry standards.

Supreme Court of Ohio reviewed when synthetic drugs were made illegal this week

Two state appeals courts disagree about whether the legislature made “analog,” or synthetic, drugs illegal in 2011 or 2012. The conflict involves two legislative bills that address controlled substance analogs, which have a similar effect to regulated drugs but are manufactured with a slightly different chemical makeup to evade drug laws. The Ohio Supreme Court heard arguments on the issue on earlier this week.

BCI, OPOTA, and BCI Crime Laboratories receive re-accreditation

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine announced recently that the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI), BCI's crime laboratories, and the Ohio Peace Officer Training Academy (OPOTA) all recently received re-accreditation.

Filing error costs sex offender his appeal

A man who was convicted of various sex offenses 15 years ago lost his appeal recently because he filed a motion to vacate his life sentence under the wrong case number.

AARP poll of Ohio women shows desire for action on Social Security

Immediate action on Social Security is what nearly three-quarters of Ohio female voters 50 years old and older want from their next president and U.S. Congress, according to the results of a new AARP Ohio poll.

New Minnesota firm to address alcoholism among attorneys

A new firm based in Minneapolis, Minn. aims to tackle rampant alcoholism in the legal profession.